Brexit law change could restrict access to UK river pollution data

A ineligible close to entree biology information, which activists and researchers person utilized to uncover the unlawful merchandise of earthy sewage into UK rivers, could beryllium mislaid arsenic portion of the UK’s ineligible disentangling from the European Union. Without these Environmental Information Regulations (EIRs), it could beryllium overmuch harder to clasp h2o firms and authorities bodies to account, campaigners person warned.

“The nationalist person a close to recognize what’s happening successful their section situation and galore of our representatives trust connected EIRs for localised information connected sewage discharges successful their areas,” says Louise Reddy astatine Surfers Against Sewage, a radical that monitors h2o prime astatine much than 400 stream and coastal locations successful the UK. “The scrapping of EIRs would beryllium precise problematic – we should beryllium taking much steps towards transparency, not 3 steps back.”

EIRs are akin to the UK’s state of accusation law, which allows anyone to petition accusation held by nationalist bodies. Crucially, the biology mentation requires immoderate backstage companies, specified arsenic h2o firms, to respond to requests arsenic well. This was lone clarified successful 2015, erstwhile biology radical Fish Legal took h2o companies Yorkshire Water and United Utilities to the European Court of Justice aft they refused to disclose information astir their merchandise of earthy sewage into h2o bodies.

Fish Legal won the lawsuit aft arguing that h2o firms were nationalist entities and truthful legally bound to merchandise biology accusation via EIRs. The ruling meant h2o firms were forced to merchandise data. “It was a long, hard fight,” says Penny Gane astatine Fish Legal. “I ne'er thought we’d person to revisit it.”

EIRs besides helped bring wider nationalist attraction to sewage overflows successful 2021 erstwhile Peter Hammond, a retired mathematics prof astatine University College London, was capable to uncover details connected the wide merchandise of earthy sewage into UK rivers by h2o firms. The information released nether the authorities showed that the standard of earthy sewage discharge by h2o firms was 10 times higher than the UK’s Environment Agency had antecedently estimated.  “I couldn’t bash immoderate of the enactment that I’ve done without EIRs,” says Hammond.

But now, the beingness of EIRs is threatened by the Retained EU Law Bill, which is presently going done the UK’s parliament and volition spot thousands of EU-derived laws expire astatine the extremity of 2023 unless they are specifically kept successful UK law. Gane fears EIRs, which are an implementation of an EU-wide directive connected entree to biology information, volition beryllium overlooked by officials who person a mammoth task of sifting done the assorted laws encompassed by the bill.

“There’s a batch of uncertainty astir the existent measure itself – we conscionable don’t cognize what the reasoning is down closed doors,” she says. “There’s perfectly nary transparency astir however this process is moving and yet they’re moving precise quickly.”

Other biology groups are besides disquieted astir losing this cardinal tool. “The Retained EU Law Bill has the imaginable to weaken our legislative framework, impacting connected the aboriginal wellness of our rivers,” says Tessa Wardley astatine the Rivers Trust. The nonaccomplishment of EIRs would weaken entree to information that helps 3rd parties clasp polluters to relationship wherever the authorities and regulators are failing successful their enforcement duties, she says.

EIRs whitethorn not beryllium the lone casualty of the large Brexit untangling. “The Environmental Information Regulations are amongst thousands of laws that are captious successful protecting our environment,” says Sandy Luk astatine the Marine Conservation Society. The sheer enormity of the task progressive successful executing the Retained EU Law Bill means that determination are apt to beryllium antagonistic impacts, she says, “either due to the fact that laws are accidentally sunsetted due to the fact that they weren’t caught successful immoderate list, oregon due to the fact that amendments volition beryllium suggested that weaken the existing ineligible framework.”

“The h2o manufacture supports calls to support cardinal authorities threatened by the Retained EU Law Bill that safeguards our rivers, seas and drinking h2o quality, including Environment Information Regulations,” says a spokesperson for manufacture assemblage Water UK. “Water companies stay committed to implicit transparency, careless of the government’s decisions astir the bill.”

“We are unequivocal that reviewing our retained EU instrumentality volition not travel astatine the disbursal of the UK’s already precocious standards,” says a spokesperson for the government’s Department for Food, Environment and Rural Affairs (Defra). “As with each retained EU law, the accessibility of biology accusation is being cautiously considered.”

But Gane says she wants much than platitudes from Defra connected this issue. “We person a groundswell of enactment down america present and we volition bash everything that we tin to marque definite that the close to entree biology accusation is protected.”

Topics: