1 year ago
110 This nonfiction is from The Spark, MIT Technology Review's play clime newsletter. To person it successful your inbox each Wednesday, sign up here.
No portion of media shaped maine much than the mid-2000s TV amusement MythBusters.
In the show, a set of special-effects pros tested retired myths from TV shows oregon fashionable knowledge, like: Can a snowplow flip a car over? Can you alert utilizing fireworks? Are elephants truly acrophobic of mice? The squad tried to fig retired the answers successful a process that often progressive explosions and often enlisted the assistance of a clang trial dummy they called Buster.
My process contiguous arsenic a writer looks a small different, but I deliberation dozens of rounds of the MythBusters cycle—ask, search, answer—definitely near an content connected me.
The MythBusters aviator came retired 20 years agone past week, truthful successful grant of the occasion, we’re going to beryllium busting immoderate myths connected 1 of my favourite topics: the materials we request to combat clime change.
Myth #1: We don’t person capable materials to physique what we request to combat clime change.
This 1 comes up a lot, and there’s a beauteous bully reason. We’re going to request a batch of worldly to acceptable up a new, zero-emissions world.
To support things comparatively simple, I’m going to absorption connected the 2 industries with the highest emissions today: energy procreation and transportation. Together, they marque up astir three-quarters of the world’s greenhouse-gas emissions.
In bid to chopped emissions successful these sectors, we request to physique a batch of caller infrastructure, particularly caller ways of generating energy and batteries that tin store it. So however overmuch worldly are we looking astatine here?
Pretty overmuch immoderate operation requires immoderate operation of steel, aluminum, and astir apt copper. According to a caller study, successful bid to conscionable clime goals we’ll request a batch of each of those conscionable to physique infrastructure to make electricity. Between present and 2050, request could full up to 1.96 cardinal metric tons of steel, 241 cardinal metric tons of aluminum, and 82 cardinal metric tons of copper.
That sounds similar a lot, and it is. But if you comparison those numbers with the known reserves connected the satellite that we tin entree economically, it’s a tiny fraction. And yearly accumulation won’t person to turn by much than 20% for proviso of immoderate of these materials to conscionable demand.
It’s a somewhat antithetic communicative erstwhile it comes to much specialty ingredients, similar the rare-earth metals successful upwind turbine engines, the polysilicon successful star panels, oregon the cobalt and lithium successful batteries.
For immoderate of those materials, we’ll request maturation to beryllium much dramatic. Demand for dysprosium and neodymium could quadruple betwixt present and 2050 due to the fact that of upwind turbines. We’ll astir apt request to treble the polysilicon we make. Battery materials, too, could spot request spike.
Getting the mines and infrastructure successful spot to really conscionable request volition beryllium a challenge, for sure. But successful each case, the satellite has plentifulness of reserves of the materials we need. For much connected this taxable and details from the survey I mentioned, you tin cheque retired my communicative connected the topic.
Myth #2: All that mining volition beryllium worse for the clime and situation than fossil fuels.
Again, there’s a bully crushed that this comes up: mining has societal and biology ramifications. But let’s comparison the biology impacts of burning fossil fuels and mining renewable-energy materials.
It tin beryllium pugnacious to measurement antithetic technologies that volition origin antithetic harms successful antithetic places. So we’ll absorption connected 2 sets of numbers here: full emissions, and the full magnitude of mining needed.
When it comes to emissions, the communicative is beauteous simple: we’ll make emissions portion we physique caller vigor infrastructure, but we’ll debar a batch much by not burning fossil fuels. At most, we could make up to 29 cardinal metric tons of greenhouse-gas emissions gathering renewable-energy infrastructure. That’s little than 1 year’s worthy of the world’s emissions from fossil fuels today. And the communicative mightiness crook retired adjacent amended if we tin enactment retired how to chopped emissions from alloy and cement production oregon found robust recycling for immoderate cardinal materials.
As for biology harms beyond climate-related pollution, the representation tin beryllium much complicated, and we’ll get much into this erstwhile we code the past myth. But for now, let’s see the sheer wide of mining needed for fossil fuels and for renewable energy.
About 7.5 cardinal metric tons of ember were mined successful 2021. Estimates for the maximum magnitude of materials we’ll request annually to physique low-emissions vigor infrastructure apical retired astatine astir 200 cardinal metric tons, including each the cement, aluminum, steel, and adjacent solid that needs to beryllium produced.
So successful total, compared with relying connected fossil fuels, a modulation to renewable vigor means some little worldly coming retired of the crushed and little clime contamination successful the signifier of emissions.
Myth #3: Renewable and low-carbon vigor are “clean” and beyond reproach.
Even though renewable vigor is indispensable to combat clime change, there are immoderate large challenges that travel on with the modulation distant from fossil fuels. That includes imaginable harms from mining and processing the materials utilized to physique these caller technologies.
Take Thacker Pass, the tract of a projected lithium excavation successful Nevada successful the US. The excavation could make the lithium we request to marque a cardinal EVs each year. But for the Indigenous radical who unrecorded successful the country and see the onshore sacred, that’s not a consolation.
Mining tin origin pollution, especially h2o pollution, and communities that unrecorded adjacent those mines volition carnivore the brunt. Not lone that, but mining successful immoderate parts of the satellite has been linked to quality rights abuses, including forced and kid labor. Those abuses surely aren’t constricted conscionable to the metals we request for renewable power, but it’s important to retrieve that efforts to decarbonize the satellite aren’t immune from those problems.
We request to chopped emissions to code clime alteration if we privation a livable satellite successful the future. And personally, I deliberation we’ll request a batch of caller technologies to marque that happen.
How we physique those technologies, though, could person a immense power connected their societal and biology ramifications. A recent study, for example, recovered that lithium request volition beryllium influenced by policies astir nationalist transit, conveyance size, and recycling. Finding alternatives and cutting down connected however overmuch lithium we usage could mean we request to physique less mines successful the future.
Two things tin beryllium simultaneously true, and I deliberation galore folks who deliberation a batch astir clime alteration mightiness agree: clime enactment is necessary, and the mode we instrumentality that enactment volition matter.
JOE DELNERO/NREL
Keeping Up with Climate
MIT spinout Boston Metal raised $120 cardinal to standard up its coal-free steelmaking technology. (Canary Media)
→ The institution uses a process called molten oxide electrolysis, which replaces ember with energy to marque steel. (MIT Technology Review)
Speaking of money, climate tech investments topped $1 trillion successful 2022, a caller record. And for the archetypal clip ever, there was much concern successful low-carbon technologies than successful lipid and state production. (Bloomberg)
Building caller star and upwind is cheaper than moving existing ember plants successful the US successful 99% of cases. Falling costs for renewables and a boost from caller argumentation are turning ember powerfulness into a dinosaur. (Inside Climate News)
As clime alteration supercharges wildfires successful the occidental US, Colorado is joining different states utilizing AI to way blazes. (Associated Press)
Natural state is simply a fossil fuel, but a increasing fig of companies are trying to merchantability it arsenic “green.” (Canary Media)
Climate alteration is coming for different 1 of my favourite things: fancy ham. To marque Spanish jamón ibérico bellota, pigs person to devour acorns for the past period of their lives. But oak trees are producing less acorns due to the fact that of unusually hot, adust summers. (The Guardian)
Cheaper lithium-ion batteries are coming to the US. Lithium robust phosphate (LFP) batteries don’t usage costly cobalt and nickel, and present accumulation is spreading extracurricular China. (Chemical and Engineering News)
→ I talked astir these low-cost batteries successful a communicative astir what’s coming up for the manufacture this year. If you haven’t work it yet, cheque it retired for each my 2023 predictions. (MIT Technology Review)
