Chinese apps remain hugely popular in the U.S. despite efforts to ban TikTok

For respective years now, ByteDance's TikTok has been the absorption of lawmakers and quality officials who fearfulness it could beryllium utilized to spy connected Americans. Those concerns took halfway signifier during a five-hour grilling of TikTok's CEO backmost successful March.

But portion TikTok has been the 1 successful the spotlight, different Chinese apps that contiguous akin issues are besides experiencing monolithic popularity successful the U.S.

Concerns astir ByteDance stem successful ample portion from a nationalist information instrumentality that gives the Chinese authorities powerfulness to entree wide swaths of concern accusation if it claims to beryllium for a nationalist information purpose. U.S. quality officials and lawmakers fearfulness that the Chinese authorities could efficaciously entree immoderate information that China-based app companies person collected from American users, from email addresses to idiosyncratic interests to driver's licenses.

But that doesn't look to person swayed galore consumers, arsenic respective China-based apps are inactive booming successful the U.S.

For example, the buying app Temu, owned by China-based PDD Holdings, has the fig 2 spot connected the Apple App Store among escaped apps arsenic of precocious May. It besides held the fig 12 spot among integer retailers successful the 2022 vacation play for unsocial visitors to its site, topping stores similar Kohl's, Wayfair and Nordstrom, according to Insider Intelligence, which besides credits visibility connected TikTok for its rise.

Meanwhile, ByteDance-owned apps CapCut and TikTok clasp the 4th and 5th spots connected the App Store rankings. Chinese accelerated manner marque Shein holds fourteenth.

And betwixt precocious March and aboriginal April, aft the TikTok CEO proceeding earlier Congress, ByteDance's Lemon8, saw astir 1 cardinal downloads successful the U.S., Insider Intelligence reported based connected information from Apptopia. It's an app with similarities to Pinterest and Meta's Instagram.

These apps stock immoderate of the features that person disquieted the U.S. authorities astir TikTok, including astir whether immoderate of these firms adequately support U.S. idiosyncratic information erstwhile operating retired of China (TikTok has stressed that U.S. idiosyncratic accusation is lone stored connected servers extracurricular of China). Like TikTok, these apps cod idiosyncratic information, tin analyse trends successful their interests and usage algorithms to people consumers with products oregon accusation that is apt to support them engaged with the service.

But experts connected China and societal media accidental determination are important differences betwixt these apps and TikTok which mightiness explicate the comparative deficiency of attraction connected them. Among the astir important of those features is the standard of their beingness successful the U.S.

Even arsenic they grow, the U.S. userbase of galore fashionable Chinese apps is inactive dwarfed by TikTok's monolithic U.S. assemblage of 150 cardinal monthly progressive users.

TikTok sister app Lemon8, for instance, has an estimated 1.8 cardinal monthly progressive users successful the U.S., according to Apptopia.

While TikTok has had 415 cardinal downloads successful the U.S. since its motorboat here, CapCut has had 99 million, Temu 67 cardinal and Lemon8 1.2 million, according to Apptopia.

Only Shein surpasses TikTok successful downloads among this radical of apps, though it launched acold earlier successful the U.S. successful 2014. Shein's app has 855 cardinal downloads successful the U.S. since its debut, though Apptopia estimates it has astir 22 cardinal monthly progressive users.

"An app with a thousand, oregon adjacent a cardinal users successful the U.S. does not contiguous the aforesaid wide cybersecurity menace that an app with 100 cardinal users has," said Lindsay Gorman, elder chap for emerging technologies astatine the German Marshall Fund's Alliance for Securing Democracy.

Gorman said arsenic the U.S. considers the menace posed by TikTok, it volition besides request to make a model for however to measure the comparative hazard of Chinese apps. The standard should beryllium 1 factor, she said, and the benignant of app, including its quality to dispersed propaganda, should beryllium another.

"The quality for a Chinese exertion level to correspond captious accusation infrastructure successful a ideology has to beryllium portion of that calculus erstwhile assessing risk," Gorman said. "That's wherever I deliberation the analogies with powerfulness grids oregon vigor infrastructure are applicable. We we would not let the authoritarian authorities to physique important components of our vigor infrastructure and trust connected an authoritarian authorities for that."

That means that an app similar ByteDance's CapCut whitethorn contiguous a little risk, some due to the fact that of its smaller idiosyncratic basal and due to the fact that it's meant to edit videos, alternatively than administer them.

"We're truly astatine the opening stages of adjacent recognizing that a broader characterization and categorization is really needed," Gorman said, adding that alternatively than playing whack-a-mole with Chinese exertion that poses a menace to U.S. nationalist security, the state should make a much systematic framework.

But successful the meantime, U.S. consumers proceed to crook to Chinese apps.

"Among the astir downloaded apps consistently are Chinese-based ones similar Temu and CapCut," said Jasmine Enberg, main expert covering societal media astatine Insider Intelligence. "And past of course, there's the aboriginal maturation of Lemon8, which suggests that the appetite for Chinese apps successful the U.S. is inactive growing."

For e-commerce apps, the hazard of spreading harmful misinformation whitethorn not beryllium arsenic precocious arsenic connected a societal media service. An e-commerce level similar Temu oregon Shein is apt a little viable level to dispersed propaganda than a video app similar TikTok.

"People conscionable aren't truly spending the aforesaid magnitude of clip connected commerce apps and they're not exposed needfully to the aforesaid benignant of contented that could perchance person a antagonistic interaction connected young people," Enberg said. "I besides don't needfully deliberation that the transportation to China for immoderate of these apps is arsenic wide to the mean user and I besides don't deliberation that consumers are truly going astir reasoning astir wherever the apps that they're utilizing originate from."

Still, the U.S. could find a crushed for concern. A caller CNN report that recovered Temu sister institution Pinduoduo, a buying app fashionable successful China, contained malware. The genitor institution of some apps, PDD Holdings, did not respond to a petition for comment. Research unit astatine the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission pointed to that study successful assessing Temu's information risks, though an expert precocious told CNBC that Temu has not been arsenic "aggressive" successful requesting entree to consumers' information arsenic Pinduoduo.

At slightest 1 radical has viewed the unit connected TikTok arsenic an optimal clip to rise concerns with different Chinese institution fashionable successful the U.S.: Shein. The radical Shut Down Shein, which is simply a "coalition of individuals, American brands and quality rights organizations," according to enforcement manager Chapin Fay, launched the time that TikTok's CEO was hauled earlier Congress.

"We were benignant of agnostic connected the timing, but we wanted to marque definite that portion radical are talking astir TikTok, there's this different nefarious actor, Shein, who's besides collecting information and doing it each nether the radar and besides doing these different adjacent worse things similar enslaved labor," said Fay, managing manager of Actum consulting firm.

The radical specifically takes contented with Shein's alleged usage of forced labor, arsenic Bloomberg reported past twelvemonth that tests revealed that fabric successful apparel shipped to the U.S. were linked to a portion successful China wherever the U.S. authorities has said forced labour is deployed. China has denied the usage of forced labor.

Shut Down Shein besides rails against the company's alleged usage of an import loophole to debar tariffs. Through the de minimis commercialized taxation exemption, the radical says, idiosyncratic customers go the importer of their accelerated manner goods, a signifier that came up astatine a caller hearing by the House Select Committee connected Strategic Competition betwixt the United States and the Chinese Communist Party.

A Shein spokesperson said successful a connection that it "complies with the home taxation legislations of the countries successful which it operates." The spokesperson besides said that Shein has "zero tolerance for forced labor," takes earnestly visibility crossed its proviso concatenation and requires suppliers to travel a "strict codification of conduct."

Fay said it's important to admit that the mode Shein has been capable to turn its marque and summation caller customers, successful ample portion via alleged influencer hauls, is done TikTok.

Faced with nationalist information worries implicit TikTok, lawmakers person considered respective proposals that could pb to a ban. But critics fearfulness immoderate projected solutions could make a slippery slope of unintended consequences. And immoderate accidental the astir effectual semipermanent solution for curbing the usage of Chinese apps whitethorn beryllium fostering an situation for robust alternatives to grow.

Perhaps the astir salient of the bills that could pb to TikTok's prohibition successful the U.S., the RESTRICT Act, would springiness the Commerce Secretary the powerfulness to urge barring exertion that comes from a prime radical of overseas adversary countries if they find the risks cannot beryllium sufficiently mitigated otherwise.

Though the connection rapidly garnered superior attraction for its heavy-hitting radical of sponsors, including Senate Intelligence Committee Chair Mark Warner, D-Va., and Commerce subcommittee connected communications ranking subordinate John Thune, R-S.D., it's since appeared to suffer the aboriginal momentum. That's owed successful portion to concerns raised by the tech manufacture and others that the measure could springiness the enforcement subdivision wide powerfulness to question a prohibition connected definite technology.

"While I recognize that Americans bask the convenience of Chinese e-commerce and the originative tools of galore Chinese communications apps, we person to reckon with the information that these companies yet are beholden to the demands of the Chinese government," Warner said successful a statement. "We've had an important and overdue speech astir the predatory and invasive practices of U.S. tech firms successful caller years; those aforesaid concerns are valid with the increasing sway of these overseas apps – and past exacerbated by the mode successful which these PRC-based companies service arsenic instruments of PRC power."

One of those critics of the bill's existent scope is Andy Yen, CEO of Proton, which makes an encrypted email work and VPN. While Yen believes that TikTok should beryllium banned successful the U.S., helium fears the RESTRICT Act is presently excessively wide to efficaciously bash truthful without further consequences.

In a caller blog post, Yen argued that the measure would springiness the Commerce Secretary overly-broad powerfulness to designate further governments arsenic overseas adversaries and feared that ambiguous connection successful the measure could beryllium utilized to penalize individuals who usage VPNs to entree apps that are banned successful the U.S.

In the post, Yen suggested these issues could beryllium resolved with changes to the bill's connection to marque it much targeted and constricted successful scope.

Speaking connected the "Pivot" podcast recently, Warner stressed the request for a rules-based attack that could beryllium legally upheld to woody with tech from overseas adversaries. He said helium believes disapproval of the bill, including that it would people idiosyncratic VPN users oregon that U.S. companies that bash concern successful China could beryllium swept up successful enforcement action, is not valid, though helium said helium is unfastened to amending the measure to marque that much clear.

"There is simply a precise morganatic nationalist information interest here," Yen said. "So I deliberation it is thing that regulators bash request to tackle and this is wherefore Congress is trying bash something. But I deliberation we request to bash it successful a mode that doesn't undermine the values of state and ideology that marque America antithetic from China."

Still, a TikTok prohibition would person different effects successful the U.S., similar yielding much marketplace stock to existing tech giants successful the U.S. similar Meta's Facebook and Instagram. Proton has been an progressive proponent of antitrust betterment to make what immoderate companies spot arsenic a much level playing tract for tech developers successful the U.S.

Yen said the solution to creating much competitory integer markets successful the U.S. is not to let risky Chinese companies to tally rampant, but alternatively "to person a level playing tract that tin let different American companies oregon European companies to vie successful the U.S. fairly."

That's a extremity shared by Jonathan Ward, an adept connected China who founded the Atlas Organization consulting firm.

"The champion mode that we tin bash this is to make alternatives," Ward said. "Because adjacent if these companies don't instrumentality basal successful our ain market, adjacent if we're capable to successfully contradict them entree here, arsenic we did with Huawei, they tin flourish successful different parts of the world," helium added, referring to the Chinese telecom institution that's been placed connected a U.S. entity database implicit nationalist information concerns.

"We're besides going to person to basal up American and escaped satellite alternatives to these companies due to the fact that you can't fto them instrumentality implicit industries that substance oregon make apps that go integral to the cloth of our societies," Ward said. "And that's going to necessitate an effort that goes beyond the Congress and into the benignant of full strategy of democracies worldwide."

Subscribe to CNBC connected YouTube.

WATCH: Montana's TikTok prohibition is simply a 'clear violation' of the First Amendment, says NetChoice VP Carl Szabo