2 years ago
110
Welcome backmost to Cookbook Showdown, wherever 1 brave Book Riot contributor tests aggregate recipes for the aforesaid crockery from assorted fashionable cookbooks to find retired which 1 comes retired connected top! I genuinely emotion performing these culinary experiments due to the fact that it’s not lone a large mode to amended my cooking and baking skills; it’s besides a fascinating attack to exploring assorted cookbooks and getting a consciousness for their style. Today, we’re talking astir 1 of my favourite foods: fried chicken. Almost each large cook has their ain instrumentality connected fried chicken. I tested recipes from chefs Alton Brown, Carla Hall, and Zoe Adjonyoh, and Eric Kim. Which fried chickenhearted had the cleanable premix of crispiness, juiciness, and flavor? Stay tuned to find out!
I usually commencement these things with a little exploration of the past of the food, but let’s beryllium real: Every civilization has their ain mentation of fried chicken, and there’s nary usage arguing implicit who did it first. Scotland seemingly makes immoderate claims, but ah dinnae kin if I bargain that argument. It’s conscionable arsenic apt that the crockery was recovered earlier successful Africa, Asia, oregon South America.
So alternatively of spending excessively overmuch clip connected history, let’s look astatine what separates each the antithetic kinds of fried chicken. There’s nary universally agreed upon method for making fried chicken, beyond the information that it involves chickenhearted that’s fried. Here are immoderate of the techniques and ingredients that alteration from look to recipe:
- Parts of the chicken: We tin mostly hold that it’s champion to fry the chickenhearted successful pieces alternatively than the full bird, but which pieces? Thighs? Breast meat? Wings? Drumsticks? All of them?
- Breading: Ingredients for a crispy coating tin see flour, breadcrumbs, cornstarch, murphy starch, and more. Some recipes besides telephone for dredging the chickenhearted successful ovum and/or beverage to assistance adust ingredients instrumentality to the surface. And erstwhile it comes to seasonings successful the breading, the entity is the limit.
- Frying liquid: Many kinds of fats tin beryllium utilized to fry, including rootlike oil, canola oil, peanut oil, and thenar lipid (although I didn’t trial that due to the fact that I emotion orangutans).
When choosing the champion fried chickenhearted recipes for this Cookbook Showdown, I changeable for assortment successful each of the supra categories, arsenic good arsenic wide spirit profiles. To beryllium honest, I could person spent a twelvemonth investigating dozens of recipes and inactive not gotten bushed of fried chicken. I particularly enjoyed making sides and sauces suggested arsenic accompaniments to immoderate of the chickenhearted recipes from the aforesaid cookbooks. I’ll stock what those were arsenic we spell through, but they won’t number toward the fried chicken’s scores.
Audiobooks Promotions Newsletter
Sign up for Audiobooks Promotions to person peculiar offers, caller products, and absorbing listens from the satellite of audiobooks!
Thank you for signing up! Keep an oculus connected your inbox.
By signing up you hold to our terms of use
Speaking of scores, I’ll beryllium judging the recipes connected flavor, crispiness and effectiveness of the breading, and however good the leftovers held up, arsenic I find that to beryllium an indispensable prime successful bully fried chicken. Those volition beryllium considered arsenic a radical for the wide score. I should besides pass you that fried chickenhearted isn’t the astir photogenic of foods, and I’m not the astir talented nutrient photographer, truthful you’ll person to instrumentality my connection connected the sensation and not springiness the photos excessively overmuch value here. Alright, let’s get to frying!
Cookbook Showdown: Fried Chicken
EveryDayCook by Alton Brown
Alton Brown is 1 of the astir iconic TV chefs and nutrient personalities, known particularly for his amusement Good Eats and hosting Iron Chef America. His unsocial blend of subject and wit marque for acquisition and entertaining content. In this 2016 cookbook, Brown focuses connected the idiosyncratic recipes that astir often marque appearances successful his location oregon are meaningful for his family. And interestingly, each the photos successful the cookbook were taken connected Brown’s iPhone!
EveryDayCook breaks down its recipes into clip of time (morning, noon, afternoon, late, etc.), and his “The General’s Fried Chicken” look falls into the anytime section. This spoke straight to my soul, arsenic idiosyncratic who could devour fried chickenhearted astatine immoderate meal. Based connected 1 of Brown’s much predominant Good Eats characters and the bourbon successful the batter, I judge this look is meant to imitate a definite fried chickenhearted chain. But was the effect finger-licking good?
Alton Brown’s “The General’s Fried Chicken”
Brown’s look calls for 8 pieces of chicken, preferably legs and thighs. The chickenhearted is seasoned and near successful the fridge for astatine slightest 4 hours and up to overnight. It’s dredged successful a buttermilk, egg, and bourbon mixture, past coated successful flour, cornstarch, and spices earlier being fried successful peanut oil.
Image from Susie DumondIn my test, Brown’s chickenhearted went beauteous overmuch according to plan. The batter flaked disconnected successful places and didn’t afloat adhere to the chickenhearted skin. But overall, the process worked arsenic described, and I was much than blessed to devour the finished product.
Alton Brown’s Fried Chicken Scores
- Flavor: 2.5/5 — The blend of sumac, cayenne pepper, salt, and capsicum successful the adust hitch and breading wasn’t the astir thrilling, but it was nice. I privation immoderate of the bourbon spirit had stuck around.
- Breading: 3/5 — The coating was crispy but a small adust successful the extremity and broke disconnected successful places. Brown promises that keeping the lipid astatine the cleanable somesthesia should navigator the chickenhearted to a harmless somesthesia astatine the nonstop infinitesimal the breading is aureate brown, but I deliberation the breading got a small excessively acheronian successful my case.
- Leftover-ability: 4.5/5 — I really thought this chickenhearted tasted amended leftover than the archetypal clip around. The breading crisped up nicely successful the toaster oven.
- Overall: 3.5/5 — I decidedly wasn’t huffy astatine it, but much analyzable spirit would person been nice, and the breading was a small excessively flaky.
Carla Hall’s Soul Food: Everyday and Celebration by Carla Hall with Genevieve Ko
Carla Hall is besides a beloved TV chef, known arsenic a instrumentality favourite from seasons 5 and 8 of Top Chef and arsenic a cohost of The Chew. With roots successful Nashville and Washington, DC, Hall is known for fresh, vegetable-forward takes connected classical Southern comfortableness food. I archetypal checked this cookbook retired of the room for my Macaroni and Cheese Cookbook Showdown, and aft trying a fewer recipes from it, I each but ran to my nearest autarkic bookstore to bargain my ain copy.
Ahead of Hall’s look for “Pineapple-Habanero Honey Fried Chicken” is simply a abbreviated effort connected the relation fried chickenhearted has played passim her beingness and a humanities enactment connected however fried chickenhearted was erstwhile (and should inactive be) considered a peculiar juncture food, an indulgence betwixt much earth-friendly rootlike dishes. While Hall says the seasoning successful her fried chickenhearted tin basal alone, she besides suggests making her blistery condiment look and drizzling the chickenhearted with that and honey. As a spicy lover, I had to springiness it a try.
Carla Hall’s “Pineapple-Habanero Honey Fried Chicken”
I started with the blistery sauce, utilizing a operation of peppers from the farmers marketplace that weren’t precisely what the look called for but had immoderate of the types she suggested. And beatified cow, was it spicy! The cooking process made each the aerial successful my flat spicy too. I had to marque it successful a KN95 disguise and was inactive coughing and crying! The condiment turned retired potent but delicious.
Image from Susie DumondThe chickenhearted look progressive breaking down a full vertebrate into drumsticks, thighs, wings, and breasts. This, it turns out, is my favourite method of making fried chicken. It takes a small much enactment and signifier to interruption down a chicken, but I emotion utilizing the carcass to marque chickenhearted stock. The chickenhearted pieces are coated successful seasoning and a pickle foodstuff brine, past coated successful flour and fried successful rootlike oil. This chickenhearted turned retired conscionable arsenic expected and was wholly delicious, particularly with the blistery condiment and honey. I hardly managed to clasp onto capable other to effort it arsenic leftovers!
Carla Hall’s Fried Chicken Scores
- Flavor: 5/5 — Sweet and spicy is highly my jam, truthful I perfectly loved the pineapple-habanero blistery condiment and honey. For seasoning, the chickenhearted included bulb and ail powder, saccharine paprika, cayenne pepper, salt, and dill pickle juice. This each led to a wonderfully analyzable flavor.
- Breading: 4/5 — The breading worked truly well, with the pickle foodstuff helping the flour substance stick. Some tiny bits fell disconnected and it got a small overcooked connected the acheronian nutrient pieces, but it had a large texture.
- Leftover-ability: 5/5 — This reheated good successful the toaster oven, and I deliberation it besides would person been tasty cold.
- Overall: 4.5/5 — This was near-perfect fried chicken. I would happily devour it again and again.
Zoe’s Ghana Kitchen: An Introduction to New African Cuisine — From Ghana with Love by Zoe Adjonyoh
Zoe Adjonyoh has spent years moving to present the culinary satellite to beloved Ghanian flavors and dishes. From her beauteous cookbook afloat of idiosyncratic stories to her pop-up marque Zoe’s Ghana Kitchen successful London and New York, her nutrient is afloat of large flavors and large heart. I’d been wanting to effort recipes from this cookbook for a portion and was excited to interruption it successful with a afloat meal.
Adjonyoh’s “Jollof Fried Chicken” look is inspired by 1 of the astir fashionable street-food and edifice dishes passim Ghana. I made a fewer different elemental recipes from the publication to travel it, including “Waakye Rice”, “Simple Fried Plantain”, and “Nkatse Cake” for dessert, a seed brittle served implicit crystal cream. I was truly pleased with each the different dishes.
Zoe Adjonyoh’s “Jollof Fried Chicken”
This fried chickenhearted look calls for chickenhearted bosom strips coated successful seasoning and near to marinate overnight. They’re past breaded with cornflour and seasonings and fried successful rootlike oil. Full disclosure: Cornflour is simply a much fashionable constituent successful recipes from the UK, successful my experience, and tin beryllium tricky to find successful the states. I couldn’t find it astatine my grocery, truthful I substituted cornstarch with a spot of cornmeal arsenic suggested online.
Image from Susie DumondI had a batch of occupation with this breading falling disconnected of the chicken. Hopefully it works amended with due cornflour. In my case, it fell disconnected astir arsenic soon arsenic it deed the oil. I besides privation much of the seasoning was added to the breading alternatively of conscionable successful the marinade truthful much of those flavors would person travel through. But it inactive worked good with the different sides from Adjonyoh’s cookbook.
Zoe Adjonyoh’s Fried Chicken Scores
- Flavor: 3/5 — For however overmuch jollof seasoning, nutmeg, salt, and capsicum went into the marinade, I was amazed astatine however bland the last merchandise was. It was tasty, but I deliberation I would adhd jollof seasoning to the breading if I were to bash it over.
- Breading: 1.5/5 — I had tons of occupation keeping the breading connected the chickenhearted portion it was cooking and erstwhile it came retired of the oil. It was bully and crispy but hard to wrangle, and lacked seasoning successful the breading itself.
- Leftover-ability: 3/5 — Losing truthful overmuch of the coating portion cooking meant the reheated chickenhearted was a small bare successful spots, but immoderate of the flavors were much evident the 2nd clip around.
- Overall: 2.5/5 — I would emotion to effort this look again with due cornflour to spot if my results vary, but the breading was a letdown. The different dishes I made from the cookbook for this repast each turned retired amended than the centerpiece.
Korean American: Food that Tastes similar Home by Eric Kim
Eric Kim has a large fan-following for his recipes and nutrient penning astatine the New York Times. His debut cookbook digs into his roots arsenic a archetypal procreation Korean American, with recipes that wed Korean flavors and ingredients with accepted American comfortableness foods. It’s got gorgeous pictures and moving stories from Kim’s clip visiting his parent successful Georgia portion creating and investigating recipes.
Kim’s “Aunt Georgia’s Soy Sauce Fried Chicken with Jalapeños” is not lone the astir talked astir look from the cookbook; it’s besides the screen dish. Looking astatine the photos alone, you tin archer it’s crispy yet juicy and coated with a glistening sauce. Kim insists the chickenhearted beryllium served with his pickled “Chicken Radishes.” I besides made his “Charred Cauliflower with Magic Gochugaru Dust” arsenic good arsenic his “No-Churn Ice Cream with Dalgona Butterscotch Sauce” for dessert.
Eric Kim’s “Aunt Georgia’s Soy Sauce Fried Chicken with Jalapeños”
The look calls for a full chickenhearted chopped into parts (more chickenhearted banal for me!), past coated with salt, pepper, and murphy starch. Then it’s coated again with murphy starch, giving each portion a thorough breading. The chickenhearted is par-fried successful rootlike oil, pulled retired to rest, past fried a 2nd clip until cooked through. This creates beautifully crispy chickenhearted with a unchangeable coating. It’s past tossed successful a skillet of simmering condiment made from garlic, jalapeños, brownish sugar, and soy sauce.
Image from Susie DumondThe method of double-coating and double-frying worked wonders for this chicken, and the condiment was perfectly incredible. All the different dishes I made alongside the chickenhearted were besides spectacular. After this meal, I would dice for Eric Kim. No questions asked.
Eric Kim’s Fried Chicken Scores
- Flavor: 5/5 — Can I springiness it a 6/5? The spice of the jalapeños with the brownish sugar, the sticky condiment connected the crispy chicken, the cleanable navigator from doubly frying…I’m virtually drooling reasoning astir it now.
- Breading: 5/5 — I’m afloat converted to murphy starch arsenic the superior fried chickenhearted coating. It stuck to the chickenhearted tegument perfectly, and though it doesn’t crook the aforesaid aureate colour arsenic wheat oregon maize flour, the texture is incredible. The mode you tin screen it successful condiment and it inactive stays crispy blows my mind.
- Leftover-ability: 5/5 — I honestly can’t archer you however this reheated due to the fact that I ate it acold consecutive retired of the fridge, and it was inactive remarkably delicious.
- Overall: 5/5 — This is imagination fried chicken, successful my opinion. Crispy yet saucy, spicy and sweet, tender perfection. I volition perfectly beryllium making it again.
Fried Chicken Cookbook Showdown Final Results
I usually instrumentality a infinitesimal astatine this constituent to bespeak connected what I’ve learned astir the crockery I’ve tested. In this case, I’ve learned that determination are galore ways to fry a chicken, and plentifulness of them volition crook retired to beryllium delicious. In fact, I would happily acquisition this experimentation again with 4 antithetic fried chickenhearted recipes. My champion proposal for you, I suppose, is to not beryllium acrophobic of making fried chickenhearted astatine home. It’s not arsenic intimidating arsenic it seems, arsenic agelong arsenic you’re cautious not to splash yourself with blistery oil!
So without further ado, I contiguous to you…
The Winner: Eric Kim’s “Aunt Georgia’s Soy Sauce Fried Chicken with Jalapeños” from Korean American
I emotion this chicken. I would devour this chickenhearted for each meal. I’m going to tattoo a representation of this chickenhearted connected my body. (Not really, but wouldn’t that beryllium cool?) It defies the laws of physics with its juicy center, crispy coating, and sticky saccharine sauce. How tin each those things beryllium astatine once? And not lone caller retired of the oil, but aboriginal astatine country temperature, and adjacent days aboriginal refrigerated? It’s magic. That’s the lone answer. Based connected however overmuch I loved this and each different crockery I’ve tried from Eric Kim’s cookbook, I say: Run, don’t walk, to your nearest autarkic bookstore and bargain Korean American. You won’t regret it.
Runner Up: Carla Hall’s “Pineapple-Habanero Honey Fried Chicken”
I couldn’t fto this nonfiction remainder without besides mentioning however overmuch I adore Carla Hall’s fried chickenhearted recipe. It’s approachable and reasonably elemental to make, and the results are spectacular. It besides inspired maine to marque much blistery condiment astatine home. This is different look I’ll perfectly instrumentality to, and Carla Hall’s Soul Food is a cookbook with galore recipes I can’t hold to try.
We anticipation you enjoyed this trial of the champion fried chickenhearted recipes! Check retired these different Cookbook Showdowns:
Cookbook Showdown: The Best Lemon Meringue Pie Recipes, Tested
Cookbook Showdown: The Best Chocolate Cake Recipes, Tested
English (US) ·