Entering the software economy

The acceleration of integer translation and velocity of lawsuit demands is turning astir each concern into a exertion business. Creating, using, oregon selling exertion is present a captious portion of each enterprise. But however bash companies adhd emerging technologies and innovations? 

Many companies looking to participate the bundle economy, the ecosystem of companies that make oregon are enabled by software, bash truthful done acquisitions, often by targeting startups. Evaluating the imaginable worth of these smaller companies, however, is simply a specialized skill, says Jeff Vogel, caput of the Software Strategy Group for EY-Parthenon. For companies, discovering and accounting for hidden endowment and exertion risks is simply a large origin successful a palmy merger oregon acquisition.

“They request to judge successful the market, that there’s country to turn successful that marketplace oregon country to grow the market; judge successful the company’s quality to execute; oregon judge that they’re coming with a translation thesis that they’re going to fundamentally alteration what the institution does and however it does it successful bid to admit their return,” says Vogel.

Non-technical companies often look to acquisitions, peculiarly of startups that are touting emerging technology, to marque concern processes tally much efficiently. They besides spot bundle investments offering opportunities for precocious maturation and mostly precocious gross margins. But it’s important to gauge the hazard and the reward of acquiring software, Vogel says. In the aforesaid mode that entering the bundle system tin output precocious growth, the marketplace moves fast, making it casual to suffer worth conscionable arsenic easy arsenic it is gained.

While determination are ever risks successful business, Vogel says that 1 indicator of a beardown acquisition is endowment retention and culture. A deficiency of synergy betwixt institution cultures and poorly managed oregon deployed endowment tin airs barriers to a creaseless acquisition and integration.

Full Transcript

Jeff Vogel: Glad to beryllium here.

Laurel: So, you’ve been moving successful backstage equity for years and person much than 3 decades of acquisition arsenic an entrepreneur and an enforcement successful bundle and technology. Can you overgarment a representation of the existent bundle economy?

Jeff: Sure. So, I mightiness commencement by defining what we mean by bundle economy. This word that we specify truly refers to bundle companies. So that’s beauteous wide to people. Companies that merchantability oregon licence software. That could beryllium on-premises old-school software; could beryllium much modern, SaaS-based (software-as-a-service) software. But past there’s a full caller slew of companies that radical mightiness deliberation of arsenic tech-enabled services. Services businesses that aren’t selling their licensing software. That are selling you immoderate concern oregon user service, but powering it with software.

So radical evidently cognize of companies successful selling exertion and online search, successful recruiting, successful transportation, that alteration their services with software, but they’re not selling software. So those companies. Particularly if those companies differentiate connected the software, truthful they’re not conscionable utilizing third-party, off-the-shelf bundle to present their service. But they person hundreds of bundle engineers, dozens oregon much patents, tens of millions of lines of codification erstwhile they’re processing proprietary bundle that powers their concern service. And it’s really however they differentiate adjacent though they’re not licensing software.

So, this postulation of companies that are either selling bundle oregon selling concern services that are enabled by software, that are attempting to differentiate connected that software, is what we telephone the bundle economy. And these bundle system companies stock successful communal those things I mentioned. Lots of bundle engineers, tons of code, often intelligence spot (IP), patents, and commercialized secrets down that code. And attempting to differentiate by the mode that exertion manifests itself to customers oregon enables a concern work to beryllium different, much efficient, faster, better, sometimes cheaper.

Laurel: That’s precise adjuvant to get a presumption of the full ecosystem there. So astatine EY-Parthenon, you assistance backstage equity companies with exertion acquisitions. As an industry, however does backstage equity enactment versus accidental a basal acquisition of 1 institution that acquires another?

Jeff: Yeah, sure. Good question there. So, erstwhile you deliberation astir a accepted acquisition, let’s accidental 1 tech institution buying another, determination could beryllium 3 oregon 4 families of theses driving that acquisition. It could beryllium vertical integration. Buy 1 of our suppliers and integrate it and instrumentality a middleman out. It could beryllium cross-sell and TAM (total addressable market) expansion. We privation to bargain thing that’s adjacent to wherever we are and we’ll execute synergy due to the fact that we tin cross-sell it done our customers, done our channels, done our salespeople, and vice versa. It could beryllium caller marketplace entry. We privation to participate a marketplace and it’s going to instrumentality america excessively agelong and outgo america excessively overmuch wealth to bash that organically. So we privation to get into it. Or it could beryllium immoderate signifier of transformation. We’re trying to alteration our institution implicit a play of years from 1 benignant of concern to another.

And those are each types of acquisitions that are done. You tin usually enactment them into those 3 oregon 4 buckets. And past it follows that there’s often immoderate synergy due to the fact that of those theses. It could beryllium gross synergy by cross-sell. As a gross synergy, we’re going to get much gross than the 2 companies combined due to the fact that of the quality to cross-sell. It could beryllium a outgo synergy: could beryllium that we person redundant products and we don’t request some of them. We tin marque each the customers conscionable arsenic blessed by eliminating the redundant capabilities and presumably having much businesslike merchandise development, merchandise marketing, go-to marketplace organizations.

And adjacent erstwhile you don’t spot those evident synergies, typically if you’re doing thing astatine scale, there’s ever back-office synergy. I don’t request 2 HR organizations, I don’t request 2 concern organizations, I don’t request 2 selling communications organizations. There’s usually immoderate synergy there. So, tech-on-tech oregon company-on-company, you tin often deliberation done with that lens.

Now, backstage equity, of course, wherever it’s conscionable a fiscal buyer, a backstage equity steadfast buying a company, nary of those theses that necessitate 2 companies exist, astatine slightest successful the archetypal acquisition. So erstwhile the backstage equity institution archetypal buys a tech company, they’re going to person a thesis that’s based connected content successful the merchandise and the institution and their quality to execute a instrumentality connected concern connected that. And backstage equity firms are, to beryllium precocious quartile, they’re looking for a 20% nett IRR [net interior complaint of return] implicit immoderate play of clip successful bid to bash that. So, there’s a important hurdle rate. They’re paying apical dollar for these companies, yet they person to execute apical return.

So, they request to judge successful the market, that there’s country to turn successful that marketplace oregon country to grow the market; judge successful the company’s quality to execute; oregon judge that they’re coming with a translation thesis that they’re going to fundamentally alteration what the institution does and however it does it successful bid to admit their return. So, there’s a beauteous precocious barroom and immoderate of those synergies that M&A has are not available, astatine slightest successful the archetypal acquisition. Now, it’s beauteous communal that aft that archetypal acquisition, a backstage equity steadfast mightiness make a thesis that’s astir acquiring much companies. And those consequent acquisitions, immoderate radical telephone that a level physique oregon tuck-ins, mightiness person a thesis that’s much successful enactment with what the tech-on-tech examples illustrate.

Laurel: So interestingly, erstwhile 1 exertion institution is bought, past a portfolio could beryllium perchance assumed, et cetera, and it paves a mode for much investment.

Jeff: So since you mentioned that, often that’s becoming much prevalent contiguous due to the fact that the backstage equity firms are paying up and they’re just, bargain the company, judge successful the market. And the institution thesis sometimes isn’t capable to get their return. They request to adhd standard and dollar-average down. In different words, if I’m paying 20 times EBITDA [earnings earlier interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization] and 7 times gross for the archetypal deal, and I cognize that it’s going to beryllium hard to marque my instrumentality connected that, I whitethorn request to spell find immoderate tuck-ins and immoderate different deals wherever I tin commencement recognizing immoderate of the synergies that strategics person disposable to them and bring that aggregate down. That archetypal woody mightiness beryllium done astatine those multiples. Maybe consequent deals are done astatine 60% of those multiples and your mean aggregate winds up being determination successful between. And that’s beauteous communal these days, peculiarly arsenic firms are paying up for the archetypal platform.

Laurel: So what are immoderate of those differences betwixt evaluating mature companies and startups? Because that’s got to beryllium immoderate benignant of specialized skill.

Jeff: Yeah. It’s interesting. So sometimes—there’s a small gag successful the manufacture that the earlier signifier you are, the easier it is to rise money. And 1 crushed is there’s little to diligence. So that’s wherefore diligence successful the task superior satellite looks precise antithetic than diligence successful the backstage equity world. There’s really little to diligence. There’s a small much of word sheets, punctuation “on the backmost of a napkin.” A batch of task superior is narration based; it’s believing successful the team. Because 1 happening they thatch you astatine task superior schoolhouse is the concern program that you put successful won’t beryllium the 1 that a institution is yet palmy in. So, you’re truly betting connected the team, you’re betting connected the team’s quality to pivot and navigate and find the eventual path. Because that archetypal 1 for early-stage companies is astir apt not wherever they’re going to upwind up being successful.

So, there’s not a batch to diligence and determination is marketplace hazard and determination is merchandise risk. Those are 2 large risks that you instrumentality successful early-stage investing. You determination implicit into aboriginal signifier and mature companies, marketplace is astir apt defined, the competitory acceptable is astir apt defined, and there’s astir apt a merchandise that’s doing thing due to the fact that these companies person substantive revenue. Now determination mightiness beryllium a adjacent procreation of the product, the merchandise mightiness beryllium nether competitory threat.

The merchandise mightiness request to beryllium transformed. It mightiness person what we telephone method debt. It mightiness person a re-architecture oregon a re-platforming. It mightiness beryllium an on-premises merchandise that has to determination to the unreality and go a SaaS [software-as-a-service] product. All of those are things that could beryllium roadmap objectives of a institution that you would privation to diligence due to the fact that they’re fundamentally expenses that you’re signing up for—things that the institution has to bash to support oregon amended its marketplace presumption and its fiscal illustration implicit clip that you’re betting on. And you privation to diligence those truly well. We telephone this method indebtedness “off-balance-sheet liabilities.” It’s similar deferred attraction connected a house.

So these mature products person tons of it. They’re not connected the equilibrium expanse truthful I can’t work the fiscal connection and say, “You beryllium that slope a cardinal dollars.” But nether the covers, successful betwixt the lines, there’s a assemblage of exertion and that exertion needs tender loving attraction and attraction conscionable similar a location oregon a gathering might. And successful diligence you privation to effort to recognize that. You privation to effort to recognize the marketplace needs. You privation to effort to recognize the competitory set, and the competitory landscape, and the roadmap that the institution has for navigating that. And spot if that aligns with your absorption teams and your quality to execute.

So we similar to accidental each these companies person risks and a batch of diligence is astir aligning the risks that are determination with those that you arsenic a backstage equity steadfast are good positioned to undertake. In different words, immoderate firms are consenting to unrecorded with immoderate fiscal hazard oregon immoderate merchandise hazard oregon immoderate marketplace hazard oregon immoderate endowment risk. But different risks they’re like, “no, no, no, no, we don’t instrumentality marketplace risk, but you person immoderate endowment risk, which we tin assistance with due to the fact that we’re large astatine recruiting and retaining talent.” So a batch of it isn’t that there’s nary risks successful the deal, but it’s knowing them, attempting to quantify them. And past culturally and DNA-wise, what are the types of risks that your steadfast is well-suited to taking connected and aligns with the civilization and DNA of the firm, versus what risks you conscionable can’t touch?

And for immoderate folks that are newer to tech—if you’ve been a backstage equity steadfast investing successful industrials and present you’re coming into tech, there’s a batch of merchandise and marketplace risks due to the fact that markets alteration rapidly and products person to alteration quickly. And those mightiness beryllium risks that immoderate of the newer firms investing successful tech don’t take, arsenic compared to immoderate firms that person been astir and getting utilized to bundle economies for the past 10 oregon 15 years and are amended suited to knowing the disruption and accidental that comes on with bundle investing.

Laurel: You’ve mentioned a small spot of this, of wherefore non-technical companies would privation to get emerging exertion companies, integration merchandise portfolios, cross-selling, et cetera. But what is the imaginable worth of these acquisitions successful presumption of that innovation, profit, and talent?

Jeff: We spot a batch of these non-tech companies trying to go much bundle enabled and bundle driven and participate the bundle economy. And that could beryllium for truly bully reasons. That bundle is bully for their customers. It makes immoderate concern process easier, faster, cheaper, smoother, higher quality, much automated. But it could besides beryllium for fiscal ones. Software enjoys comparatively debased friction to turn and enter, accidental for precocious growth. People spot these brainsick maturation companies successful the bundle system each the time, and successful different sectors of the system it’s hard to turn astatine those rates. High gross margins successful software. Cost of goods is simply a beauteous tiny percent of gross and what you merchantability products for. We person a batch of regularisation of 40 oregon 50 oregon 60 companies. If you don’t cognize what that is, regularisation of 40 is erstwhile you adhd unneurotic the maturation complaint of a institution with the EBITDA borderline of the company. And 40 utilized to beryllium great. If you’re increasing astatine 20% and delivering 20% EBITDA margins, that’s beauteous good.

But we’re really seeing regularisation of 50 and 60 companies successful bundle today. So combining those 2 [figures], those are typically trade-offs. I tin turn faster if I put much of my profits, if I’m a small little profitable, oregon I tin turn slower and person much profit. But erstwhile I tin bash some successful a tenable percent and I’m regularisation of 40, 50, oregon 60, that’s beauteous strong. And we spot a batch of those companies successful software, precocious multiples. People emotion that due to the fact that it means higher exits and little outgo of superior erstwhile they’re raising money. We don’t necessitate a batch of moving capital, we don’t person a batch of factories, we don’t person a batch of inventory. So managing the equilibrium expanse is simply a batch easier.

So a batch of radical are jealous of the metrics and debased friction and the acerb airy quality of the bundle system and privation to effort to marque their companies commencement looking similar that. And that’s wherefore we spot a batch of these companies either transforming themselves oregon starting to get bundle companies and effort to garner immoderate of the benefits of being successful the bundle economy.

Now, the different broadside of the coin, of course, is there’s ever a small spot of “be cautious what you privation for” due to the fact that you travel connected implicit to the bundle economy, and what’s antithetic implicit here? Well, you tin spell from zero to 100 beauteous quickly. You tin found yourself. You could not beryllium a institution 1 twelvemonth and beryllium a large subordinate and predominate the marketplace six years aboriginal successful multi-billion-dollar markets. And we’ve each seen that, peculiarly successful Silicon Valley. But the different broadside of it is you tin spell from 100 to zero beauteous darn quickly, and you’re seeing immoderate of those companies play retired contiguous also.

So determination is different broadside of the coin, and you person to person the tummy for it and you person to person the hazard illustration for it and you person to person the DNA for it and you person to person the endowment for it. So it is somewhat antithetic from moving non-software system businesses. Those are the reasons wherefore we spot these non-tech companies starting to get tech companies and participate the bundle economy.

Laurel: Just truthful everyone is clear, EBITDA is net earlier interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization, but we’re talking astir indicators and what makes a exertion institution a beardown acquisition without a crystal ball, without knowing what those palmy companies whitethorn be, the zero to 100 and beyond. What’s a bully illustration of however companies tin really commencement looking astatine immoderate indicators?

Jeff: Well, if you’re six, 12 months into it, things that I look for… Now, let’s accidental you’ve got a non-tech institution acquiring a tech institution oregon adjacent a ample tech institution acquiring a tiny tech company. When you participate the bundle economy, determination are a batch of things that are different. One of them is talent, the mode radical think, the types of radical that you hire, the civilization of these bundle system companies. And the large motion is however galore of the cardinal radical are staying around, and much importantly, what their roles are successful the company.

So erstwhile you spot companies acquired and the executives from the acquired companies commencement getting promoted and taking connected larger roles successful the acquiring organization, that’s hugely a motion that the cultures are aligning. The things that the acquired institution brings to the array are valued by the acquirer, the cultures are integrating. The benefits, adjacent if they instrumentality longer due to the fact that of integration of products and exertion and channels and markets, mightiness instrumentality a small longer. But if you spot the endowment integrating successful that way, I’d accidental that’s a beauteous bully sign. Because bundle is an intangible IP and it’s precise overmuch tied to the radical who physique it and support it. If you person endowment drains owed to culture, compensation, oregon different things aft an acquisition, that’s usually the starring indicator that the thesis is going to spell up successful smoke. So that’s the archetypal happening I look for.

Now, successful a backstage equity woody you don’t rather spot that, due to the fact that the institution is beauteous overmuch the company. In immoderate cases, the lone happening that changes is the committee of directors, particularly if a institution was good tally and a backstage equity steadfast wants to support it that way, determination whitethorn not beryllium a batch of alteration and things whitethorn conscionable spell connected arsenic normal. The lone happening that changes is the shareholders. But erstwhile it’s an operating institution being acquired, endowment is simply a bully spot to look for starring indicators.

Laurel: With a increasing fig of companies attracted to the exertion scenery arsenic you described, it seems similar a crowded market. So however tin a institution differentiate itself to enactment competitory and beryllium discerning erstwhile looking for investments?

Jeff: Yeah. So I deliberation getting those theses right. Just being a holding institution and buying thing is astir apt not the champion approach, though determination are holding institution models retired there. Doubling down connected the strategy and the M&A, immoderate radical mightiness telephone it an M&A thesis oregon the integration thesis. So let’s instrumentality examples. Vertical integration: If you’re going to vertically integrate oregon get a supplier, that could person important synergy, could person important differentiation. And if you instrumentality the clip to enactment that strategy out, find the close companies to get that acceptable the thesis, and marque definite you money the integration. Integration is not conscionable a clump of rows connected spreadsheets, but it’s really getting connected the ground, successful the weeds, figuring retired the operating models, people, the concern processes, the tools that are needed to successfully integrate to spot your thesis through. Those tin beryllium differentiating and those tin beryllium crippled changers for companies some successful the marketplace and connected the P&L.

Laurel: And you mentioned this earlier, which is the unknown-risk, high-reward facet of acquiring exertion companies, but the caller capabilities and talents is thing that a caller institution tin offer. So what are the astir communal obstacles that companies look then?

Jeff: I touched connected this before, it’ll beryllium a small redundant, but I would accidental the archetypal is you’re coming into the bundle economy, it’s caller to you. Companies tin spell from zero to 100 beauteous quickly, but they tin spell from 100 to zero. The scenery is littered with companies that were high-flyers, leaders successful their space, that are present gone and retired of business. Were fundamentally acquired successful occurrence income and somebody’s moving retired the attraction agelong process connected immoderate of these companies. So you’ve seen that successful old-school desktop publishing, you’ve seen that successful old-school CRM and ERP, you’ve seen that successful assorted vertical applications serving vertical businesses. All those sectors person had once-dominant players that didn’t innovate, possibly mislaid their cardinal talent, possibly had an upside-down equilibrium sheet, were over-leveraged, and fundamentally disappeared and went disconnected the representation arsenic speedy arsenic they came on.

Again, you tin spell from not being a institution to being the high-flyer person successful the abstraction of five, six, 7 years and conscionable arsenic quickly, perchance much quickly, spell to zero. So it’s truly important that folks acquiring these companies are investing successful them, recognize that risk, and recognize that sometimes drastic things person to beryllium done to support these companies increasing and high-flying, adjacent aft you deliberation they’ve reached their apex.

And past the different is, cultures don’t integrate. Again, touched connected this before, endowment is simply a cardinal thing. Software system companies thin to person antithetic cultures than businesses from different parts of the economy. And it’s beauteous important that that’s recognized and determination are strategies for dealing with it oregon other the endowment won’t beryllium arsenic innovative, volition person precocious attrition hazard because—I’ll permission and commencement a competitor. We’ve seen that play out. Company gets acquired, radical tally retired their non-compete oregon their retention bonus for a year, past they each spell and commencement different company, and that different institution does it adjacent better.

One happening you’ll find successful bundle is the archetypal guys to bash it are usually not the winners. In fact, often you whitethorn not cognize the archetypal guys oregon gals. The 2nd clip astir is usually better. Why? Because you larn from your mistakes. Or amended yet, you larn from idiosyncratic else’s mistakes. You person a exemplary to enactment from. The archetypal clip you’re designing a mobile phone, you’re the archetypal guys, you got to fig it each out. The 2nd time, you’re learning from the guys who got it similar 60% right, but 40% wrong.

The clip before, successful the web browser space, it wasn’t the archetypal guys who won. In the mobile telephone space, it wasn’t the archetypal guys who won. In the desktop computing space, it wasn’t the archetypal guys who won. It’s usually the 2nd oregon third. So that’s a beauteous communal taxable and often radical who were connected those archetypal teams that learned, and they spell commencement the 2nd teams. And if you person that endowment and you fto it locomotion retired the door, shame connected you.

So trying to beryllium the ones that enactment yourself retired of concern versus letting your erstwhile employees fig retired however to bash it is ever a bully idea. And I deliberation the champion companies bash that. They signifier teams, they springiness them immoderate autonomy, and they say, “Can you spell physique the adjacent procreation of our merchandise alternatively than a competitor? Go physique it.” And past that’s however companies reinvent themselves and mitigate the hazard of the endowment civilization oregon the innovation civilization walking retired the doorway oregon springing up determination else.

Laurel: It surely helps to person that past arsenic position now, but looking guardant into the future, however volition backstage equity assistance signifier the exertion scenery successful the adjacent fewer years?

Jeff: So I mean, look, it’s a small spot of the Wild West. Private equity has ne'er been truthful ascendant successful tech. I mean it’s hard to believe, but if you spell backmost 12, 13, 14 years, possibly adjacent 10, determination was astir nary backstage equity investing successful tech. Private equity firms didn’t recognize tech; they didn’t recognize each the things I mentioned. Why the precocious gross margins? Why the precocious maturation rates? I’m frightened of companies going from 100 to zero; I cognize they tin spell from zero to 100. I don’t recognize each this intangible IP that I can’t interaction and feel. It’s not successful the factory, it’s not an inventory. There was precise small investing successful tech and past determination were immoderate deals done 10, 15 years agone that were the archetypal tech deals, large take-privates. And past much firms got into it, and past immoderate specialized firms started doing lone tech. And present tech backstage equity is simply a large portion of our system and the superior markets.

Some numbers that mightiness beryllium absorbing to people. Last twelvemonth successful 2021, determination were 129 tech IPOs for $70 billion, and really a tiny fraction of that successful 2022—so far, lone 19 deals for $1.6 cardinal due to the fact that of the marketplace corrections. And if we look astatine buyouts, determination were astir arsenic many—in 2021 determination were 139 buyouts, really a small more, for $50 billion. But successful 2022, this marketplace really was truthful white-hot astatine the opening of the twelvemonth that determination were 99 deals for $60 billion. So determination were 80 much tech take-privates than determination were IPOs successful 2022. That represents 43% of the deals, by worth successful 2019 and by number, were successful the tech economy.

So tech is dominating the superior markets and backstage equity and tech are becoming a substantive information of the superior markets. More so, the drastic alteration has been connected the backstage side, and radical recognize determination are companies present that person gone private, public, private, public, private, public, bounce backmost and forth, due to the fact that determination are things you tin bash arsenic a backstage institution that you can’t bash arsenic a nationalist company. The quarterly financials marque it hard to bash things similar a SaaS transformation, to spell from large upfront contracts to recurring revenue. Makes it hard to bash large investments successful caller products, makes it hard to walk a batch of wealth connected R&D [research and development], oregon a batch of wealth connected R versus the D, improvement and maintenance. A batch of these are things that radical find are easier to bash arsenic a backstage company, extracurricular of having to study each 4th and disclose everything you’re doing to the public. Thus, you are seeing this rhythm that backstage equity is conscionable a beauteous meaningful portion of the superior markets for tech companies overall. And we’re doing bigger and bigger deals.

We worked connected a $17 cardinal deal.And I deliberation we’re going to spot a batch much deals successful that size vicinity implicit the years to come. While backstage equity has been dilatory the past six months oregon truthful with the correction, erstwhile the nationalist markets, involvement rates going up, what person you, there’s a batch of pent-up demand. There’s inactive a batch of wealth connected the sidelines successful backstage equity that’s going to beryllium invested erstwhile backstage equity pops back, which volition apt hap astatine immoderate constituent present successful the archetypal fractional of [20]23. It’s astir apt going to travel backmost with a vengeance, and I deliberation we’ll spot the effect of backstage equity connected the superior markets for tech companies beryllium arsenic important arsenic ever aboriginal successful [20]23.

Laurel: Completely fascinating. Jeff, convey you truthful overmuch for being present connected the Business Lab today.

Jeff: Appreciate it. Thank you.

This amusement is disposable wherever you get your podcasts. If you enjoyed this episode, we anticipation you’ll instrumentality a infinitesimal to complaint and reappraisal us. Business Lab is simply a accumulation of MIT Technology Review. This occurrence was produced by Giro Studios. Thanks for listening.

Learn much astir EY-Parthenon disruptive exertion solutions astatine ey.com/us/disruptivetech.

This contented was produced by Insights, the customized contented limb of MIT Technology Review. It was not written by MIT Technology Review’s editorial staff.

The views expressed successful this podcast are not needfully the views of Ernst & Young LLP oregon different members of the planetary EY organization.