How a fracking boom startup is taking its seismic science into the climate change era

In this play series, CNBC takes a look astatine companies that made the inaugural Disruptor 50 list, 10 years later.

By 2013, erstwhile Microseismic was selected for the inaugural CNBC Disruptor 50 list, it was beauteous acold from the "start" successful startup, already successful its tenth twelvemonth arsenic a company. And that preceding decennary had been 1 during which the company, which performs subsurface monitoring utilizing passive seismic technology, had grown up amid the roar successful U.S. oilfield hydraulic fracturing, amended known arsenic fracking, and which by 2013, was astir to spell bust successful a large way.

When the institution and its laminitis and CEO Peter Duncan had archetypal raised wealth from investors successful 2003, the thought wasn't to thrust the shale boom. Helping vigor companies execute environmentally delicate geological exploration was a halfway focus, with its attack much similar a stethoscope, Duncan says, compared to the accepted exertion of the time, seismic vibrators, which helium says worked much similar an ultrasound. But of each the things the institution enactment connected the database of uses for its seismic exertion erstwhile it was raising money, "frac monitoring was astatine the bottom," Duncan said. "We're not going to bash that," helium recalls saying. "A large reddish X." 

For one, determination were different players already successful the market, and the ascendant lipid services companies, including Halliburton and Baker Hughes, were buying up firms doing subject akin to Microseismic – Halliburton already owned seismic mapping institution Pinnacle Technologies.

And successful a way, Duncan thought the subject wasn't a bully lucifer for the blunt process of lipid and state drilling. "You drill a wellbore to nutrient lipid and gas, not to enactment fancy subject experiments down," helium said.

But the shale state boom, and the market, sent a antithetic message. "They told america to bash frac monitoring, and it became much invaluable to clients arsenic they started drilling agelong horizontal wells that could nary longer beryllium sensed oregon monitored with a azygous down hole," Duncan said, and Microseismic was gathering the equivalent of a large crockery microphone up connected the surface. 

Its attack made Microseismic a ascendant unit successful frac monitoring services – for a time.

"The quality of the satellite has changed," Duncan said. 

The Covid downturn successful 2020 capped adjacent to a decennary of a carnivore marketplace for lipid and culminated successful the antagonistic spot prices successful the lipid marketplace successful May 2020. Microseismic, which had go excessively babelike connected the shale boom, had to laic disconnected unit and had creditors circling it. "Quite a catastrophe," Duncan said.

And portion the satellite has changed again, and Russia's warfare successful Ukraine has led to renewed absorption connected home vigor supply, the lipid concern isn't going backmost to its reckless drilling ways. Oil and state was changing from a maturation concern to a worth business, and lipid institution absorption were overmuch much focused connected fiscal discipline. This included decisions connected wherever to regenerate reserves alternatively than conscionable effort to summation reserve maturation connected the books. "The banal marketplace started to say, 'we privation to spot lipid and state returning much wealth to shareholders, and truthful the bottommost enactment expenditure connected plays became much important than uncovering caller reserves," Duncan said.

Drilling the lowest-cost well, alternatively than getting the astir retired of each imaginable well, became the much important benchmark, and "as agelong arsenic they were getting bully capable results, and could vessel wealth to shareholders, that was bully enough, and that wounded us," Duncan said.

The concern successful the oilfields didn't spell away, but arsenic drillers concentrated operations successful cardinal acreage, the seismic services were needed to support the wells being drilled person and person together, which if not monitored decently could pb 1 good to efficaciously "steal" from an adjacent one, oregon compromise good integrity successful different ways. 

In the Permian Basin of Texas and New Mexico, operations were much apt to look similar a "wine rack" successful these post-bust days, according to Duncan, with wells astatine aggregate levels from 2,500 to 4,000 feet and the drillers trying to get arsenic overmuch arsenic they could retired of each acre. That attraction of instrumentality and infrastructure's resulting reduced costs was not bully for an lipid services company.

The seismic technology, and the mentation of geological data, had evolved rapidly. Microseismic and competitors could foretell successful existent clip however overmuch hydrocarbon a driller could get from a good to the constituent of being capable to accidental "you should support fracking for 15 oregon 20 minutes much due to the fact that that's erstwhile instrumentality connected concern volition beryllium positive, and aft that, it volition beryllium antagonistic and you should crook it off," Duncan said.

But the subject getting amended couldn't alteration an lipid assemblage responding to a marketplace that wanted much superior discipline, and lipid executives saying, "don't interest astir telling maine however to find much oil. Just assistance maine marque definite I don't harm adjacent good bores," Duncan recalled.

It was the worth proposition for the applied subject that changed.

"They had knocked truthful overmuch outgo retired of the system, from the [fracking] soil to drilling tech … that they didn't attraction anymore astir fine-tuning ROI to the nearest 2 decimal points," Duncan said.

And adjacent with the surge successful lipid prices aft the Covid crash, this isn't going to change. "The marketplace has spoken. … Frac monitoring, I person to say, has go a commodity," Duncan added.

The magnitude spent contiguous is 25% of what it was successful 2012, and the fig of frac stages is 25% of what it was successful 2012. 

"The superior subject is inactive there," helium said. "We enactment that away. We drank from the frac hose for a agelong time."

In the satellite of Silicon Valley startups, it's go cliché to speech successful presumption of concern "pivots." But dissimilar a B2C app pivoting to a B2B absorption connected information analytics, it is little communal to speech specifically astir a pivot to sinkholes and geothermal energy. The underlying seismic technological measurement attack and geology, dissimilar fickle consumers, allowed Microseismic to prosecute caller applications for its technology.

One older exertion of passive seismic monitoring which the institution has gained traction with is listening for the improvement of sinkholes, taking Microseismic into the country of civilian engineering. That's go 20%-25% of the company's income implicit the past fewer years arsenic sites from concern operations to residential complexes, airdrome runways and hotels, look to seismic monitoring arsenic a mode to spot sinkholes earlier catastrophe. While seismic investigations are done pre-construction to find existing sinkholes, determination are opportunities for caller sinkholes to make and determination had ne'er been a modular method for monitoring structures erstwhile built. And arsenic environments astir the satellite are much densely built and populated with much structures, much areas prone to sinkholes are apt to beryllium underneath caller construction. "Sinkhole detection is simply a planetary occupation and we're conscionable trying to get our arms astir it," Duncan said. 

The pivot besides took Microseismic backmost to a benignant of enactment that was the archetypal paying task it ever did: c sequestration successful Wyoming for Anadarko Petroleum (since acquired by Occidental Petroleum), a signifier of lipid drilling that uses CO2 called enhanced lipid recovery. 

As companies similar Occidental Petroleum pb with a presumption that the clime occupation isn't astir fossil fuels but emissions, CO2 sequestration is an attack that is peculiarly well-suited to Microseismic.

"Our subject is highly important successful making CO2 sequestration work, and we are heavy pursuing it," Duncan said. The institution has a Department of Energy assistance to use the exertion already successful commercialized usage connected fracking and sinkhole detection arsenic a work for CO2 sequestration sites.

When companies enactment CO2 successful the ground, they request to beryllium acrophobic astir 3 factors. The hazard of inducing seismic events that tin beryllium damaging connected the aboveground (think an earthquake). The risks related to a reservoir for CO2 maintaining its integrity. And the CO2 being sequestered not staying successful the reservoir, leaking up supra a seal oregon being driven down beneath into stone wherever it could origin seismic activity.

Duncan says passive seismic monitoring is an effectual mode to show for these risks and look astatine the dynamics of a reservoir some earlier and aft CO2 injection. "You tin perceive tiny microseismic events increasing successful magnitude, and past cognize it mightiness beryllium starring to a seismic lawsuit astatine the surface, and you tin instrumentality enactment to halt that," helium said. "You tin observe whether a  ace is forming successful the seal oregon stone that volition let the CO2 to leak extracurricular the reservoir, and arsenic a plume of CO2 grows, it volition make microseismic events."

This technological application, though, has not adjacent deed the investigating signifier yet. Microseismic is inactive successful signifier 1 of its DOE assistance focused connected plan of the system. Phase 2, scheduled for adjacent spring, is to deploy connected projects wrong the DOE-supported CarbonSafe program, respective of which the Microseismic squad has visited.

"At present, determination is tons of speech astir CO2 sequestration," Duncan said.

And large numbers. He sees the addressable marketplace present astatine 40 projects covering 20 cardinal metric tonnes of carbon, and with a extremity of increasing that to a gigaton (one cardinal tons) of CO2 by 2030. "And that's a immense maturation industry," helium said. "And radical cognize regulators person said you person to beryllium capable to show it to marque definite the CO2 is staying successful spot and not causing earthquakes."

There are competing ways to attack the geophysical problem, and close present it is simply a contention to find the astir economical mode to execute the task. 

"It feels to maine similar erstwhile we jumped into frac monitoring, the maturation curve volition beryllium benignant of similar 2008-2012 implicit the adjacent 4 years," Duncan said.

The provisions successful President Biden's Inflation Reduction Act, and the $85 per ton successful taxation credits for sequestration, volition help. "The speech was breakeven astatine $70/ton, truthful putting it up to $85 causes a batch of these projects to look a batch amended economically," helium said.

And beyond that, there's connected the bid of $2 cardinal successful funds for investigating and probe related to c sequestration. "We are beneficiaries of that," Duncan added.

The IRA is besides putting a batch of the government's billions down geothermal energy, different country wherever Microseismic sees caller usage cases for its aged fracking technology. Some of the caller investments successful geothermal vigor person been into companies porting frac procedures implicit to geothermal, looking for the places successful the rocks wherever the vigor speech is suited to vigor accumulation but wherever explorers person not yet penetrated. "That volition beryllium earthy for america to follow," Duncan said. "In bid to make geothermal resources, they volition request a bully statement of what the vigor speech is doing, what's taking place," and that includes connected the Gulf Coast and successful New Mexico, Nevada and California, arsenic good arsenic overseas successful Europe and Australia. "Anywhere the rocks are blistery it's conscionable a substance of however accelerated they get hot. The biggest atomic reactor is the halfway of the earth," Duncan said. 

That's each a agelong mode from wherever Microseismic thought the concern of its subject was headed successful 2003. "When we started the exit strategy was to amended the tech and merchantability it to a strategical buyer, a Halliburton oregon Schlumberger," Duncan said. "We waited for a sound connected the door."

That sound came successful 2010, but not from wrong the lipid industry, arsenic an auction led to a backstage equity deal, with the stated volition of yet taking Microseismic public. The institution was successful the process of restructuring for an IPO arsenic the fracking marketplace tanked, and the quality of the mode lipid and state companies were tally financially was changing. "And past Covid wholly dashed that anticipation of going public," Duncan said. "We licked our wounds and started disconnected again."

That does see the fracking businesses, which doubled successful 2020 implicit 2019 arsenic the marketplace bounced backmost sharply aft the little Covid recession, and is connected way to turn by different 30% this year. "It's moving backmost up, but I don't spot that aforesaid maturation curve arsenic it had," helium said.

As absorption successful the lipid and state manufacture changes, and vigor modulation sectors are built from the crushed up, Microseismic needs to beryllium well-equipped successful an country of subject that isn't successful its roots: instrumentality learning and AI. Duncan, who has been looking for a right-hand antheral for a agelong time, brought successful Gary Hargraves implicit the summertime arsenic main operating serviceman and president. Hargraves, who has integer services acquisition crossed industries including oil, mining, airlines and retail, and astir precocious oversaw consulting steadfast Capgemini's ESG and c tracking information solutions, is charged with merging the accepted geophysical subject of the institution with the information and integer revolution, though Duncan says, "I americium not successful a hurry to shuffle disconnected to Buffalo."

He besides says it's not a agelong for the vigor concern to beryllium astatine the forefront of machine science. "The geophysical concern has been the largest idiosyncratic of computing passim history," helium said. "Some of the archetypal machines astatine MIT were for seismic processing."

Geophysicists person ever practiced the inverse mentation of information — deriving a exemplary from a acceptable of carnal satellite measurements, successful a consciousness reversing the enactment of a geophysical process. "Machine learning and AI are conscionable much blase ways to bash that. It's the quality betwixt a calculator and a computer," Duncan said.

And arsenic successful galore industries, if it works it volition beryllium better, faster and cheaper, with signifier designation and instrumentality learning enabling what's already being done successful seismic monitoring, and successful existent time, and much afloat utilizing the powerfulness embedded successful the data. "These instrumentality learning technologies springiness you amended ways to look astatine the information and spot what we already know, but signifier it successful a mode that lets you pass it to everyone else. ... It's halfway and necessary, but not capable for the future," Duncan said.

It volition beryllium sinkholes, and c sequestration, and geothermal vigor that volition beryllium make-or-break arsenic the company. "We person to onslaught these caller markets ... and the instrumentality earring and signifier designation tin let america to bash it much wholly and reliably successful existent time," Duncan added.

Microseismic is readying again for a imaginable exit wrong the adjacent 5 years. But it is not apt to beryllium a large lipid work company. All the large work companies are pivoting to caller vigor modulation opportunities that overlap with Microseismic's caller efforts, and that gives it the accidental to beryllium its technology, Duncan said, but with large players choosing their bets selectively successful vigor transition, the eventual extremity crippled could beryllium breaking up the institution and selling the services separately, specified arsenic sinkholes to an engineering firm, and CCS to a caller vigor modulation company. 

Whichever mode it plays out, Duncan said helium is astir amazed that the institution is inactive autarkic aft 2 decades. And determination person been a batch of surprises on the mode – however the shale roar became its biggest business, followed by however rapidly the subject became commoditized successful the lipid market. And finally, amazed by the resiliency of the geophysics concern and the pivot to caller opportunities based connected the aforesaid basal science. "I instrumentality bosom from that," helium said.

Duncan says each of this possibly should not person amazed him arsenic students successful geophysical sciences person traditionally been told to not interest astir what's going connected successful the mining oregon lipid and state concern specifically. What they are told is, "Concentrate connected the geophysics of what you're doing and the geophysical implications, and there will beryllium a marketplace for what you do," helium said.

SIGN UP for our weekly, archetypal newsletter that goes beyond the list, offering a person look astatine CNBC Disruptor 50 companies, and the founders who proceed to innovate crossed each assemblage of the economy.