1 year ago
114 China Report is MIT Technology Review’s newsletter astir exertion developments successful China. Sign up to person it successful your inbox each Tuesday.
As I often say, the American radical and the Chinese radical person overmuch much successful communal than either broadside likes to admit. For example, instrumentality the shared interest astir however overmuch clip children and teenagers are spending connected TikTok (or its Chinese home version, Douyin).
On March 1, TikTok announced that it’s mounting a 60-minute default clip bounds per time for users nether 18. Those nether 13 would request a codification entered by their parents to person an further 30 minutes, portion those betwixt 13 and 18 tin marque that determination for themselves.
While the effectiveness of this measurement remains to beryllium seen (it’s surely possible, for example, to lie astir your age erstwhile registering for the app), TikTok is intelligibly responding to fashionable requests from parents and policymakers who are acrophobic that kids are overly addicted to it and different societal media platforms. In 2022, teens spent connected mean 103 minutes per time connected TikTok, beating Snapchat (72 minutes) and YouTube (67). The app has besides been found to beforehand contented astir eating disorders and self-harm to young users.
Lawmakers are taking notice: respective US senators person pushed for bills that would restrict underage users’ entree to apps similar TikTok.
But ByteDance, the genitor institution of TikTok, is nary alien to those requests. In fact, it has been dealing with akin authorities pressures successful China since astatine slightest 2018.
That year, Douyin introduced in-app parental controls, banned underage users from appearing successful livestreams, and released a “teenager mode” that lone shows whitelisted content, overmuch similar YouTube Kids. In 2019, Douyin constricted users successful teen mode to 40 minutes per day, accessible lone betwixt the hours of 6 a.m. and 10 p.m. Then, successful 2021, it made the usage of teen mode mandatory for users nether 14. So a batch of the measures that ByteDance is present starting to present extracurricular China with TikTok person already been tested aggressively with Douyin.
Why has it taken truthful agelong for TikTok to enforce screen-time limits? Some right-wing politicians and commentators are alleging existent malice from ByteDance and the Chinese authorities (“It’s astir similar they admit that exertion is influencing kids’ development, and they marque their home mentation a spinach mentation of TikTok, portion they vessel the opium mentation to the remainder of the world,” Tristan Harris, cofounder of the Center for Humane Technology and a erstwhile Google employee, told 60 Minutes.) But I don’t deliberation that the quality betwixt the 2 platforms is the effect of immoderate benignant of conspiracy. Douyin would astir apt look precise akin to TikTok were it not for however rapidly and forcefully the Chinese authorities regulates integer platforms.
The Chinese governmental strategy allows the authorities to respond swiftly to the consequences of caller tech platforms. Sometimes it’s successful effect to a wide concern, specified arsenic teen addiction to societal media. Other times it’s much astir the government’s interests, similar clamping down connected a caller merchandise that makes censorship harder. But the shared effect is that the authorities is capable to inquire platforms to marque changes rapidly without overmuch pushback.
You tin spot that intelligibly successful the Chinese government’s attack to different tech merchandise commonly accused of causing teen addiction: video games. After denouncing the games for galore years, the authorities implemented strict restrictions successful 2021: people nether 18 successful China are allowed to play video games lone betwixt 8 and 9 p.m. connected weekends and holidays; they are expected to beryllium blocked from utilizing them extracurricular those hours. Gaming companies are punished for violations, and galore person had to physique oregon licence costly individuality verification systems to enforce the rule.
When the crackdown connected video games happened successful 2021, the societal media manufacture was decidedly spooked, due to the fact that galore Chinese radical were already comparing short-video apps similar Douyin to video games successful presumption of addictiveness. It seemed arsenic though the sword of Damocles could driblet astatine immoderate time.
That anticipation seems adjacent much definite now. On February 27, the National Radio and Television Administration, China’s apical authorization connected media accumulation and consumption, said it had convened a gathering to enactment connected “enforcing the regularisation of abbreviated videos and preventing underage users from becoming addicted.” News of the gathering sent a wide awesome to Chinese societal media platforms that the authorities is not pleased with the existent measures and needs them to travel up with caller ones.
What could those caller measures look like? It could mean adjacent stricter rules astir surface clip and content. But the announcement besides mentioned immoderate different absorbing directions, similar requiring creators to get a licence to supply contented for teenagers and processing ways for the authorities to modulate the algorithms themselves. As the concern develops, we should expect to spot much innovative measures taken successful China to enforce limits connected Douyin and akin platforms.
As for the US, adjacent getting to the level of China’s existing regulations astir societal media would necessitate immoderate large changes.
To guarantee that nary teens successful China are utilizing their parents’ accounts to ticker oregon station to Douyin, each relationship is linked to the user’s existent identity, and the institution says facial designation tech is utilized to show the instauration of livestream content. Sure, those measures assistance forestall teens from uncovering workarounds, but they besides person privateness implications for each users, and I don’t judge everyone volition determine to sacrifice those rights conscionable to marque definite they tin power what children get to see.
We tin spot however the power vs. privateness trade-off has antecedently played retired successful China. Before 2019, the gaming manufacture had a theoretical regular play-time bounds for underage gamers, but it couldn’t beryllium enforced successful existent time. Now determination is simply a cardinal database created for gamers, tied to facial designation systems developed by large gaming publishers similar Tencent and NetEase, that tin verify everyone’s individuality successful seconds.
On the contented broadside of things, Douyin’s teen mode bans a slew of contented types from being shown, including videos of pranks, “superstitions,” oregon “entertainment venues”—places similar creation oregon karaoke clubs that teenagers are not expected to enter. While the contented is apt selected by ByteDance employees, societal media companies successful China are regularly punished by the authorities for failing to behaviour thorough censorship, and that means decisions astir what is suitable for teens to ticker are yet made by the state. Even the mean mentation of Douyin regularly takes down pro-LGBTQ content connected the ground that they contiguous “unhealthy and non-mainstream views connected matrimony and love.”
There is simply a dangerously bladed enactment betwixt contented moderation and taste censorship. As radical lobby for much extortion for their children, we’ll person to reply immoderate hard questions astir what those societal media limits should look like—and what we’re consenting to commercialized for them.
Do you deliberation a mandatory regular TikTok clip bounds for teenagers is necessary? Let maine cognize what you deliberation astatine zeyi@technologyreview.com.
Catch up with China
1. Over the weekend, the Chinese authorities held its “two sessions”—an yearly governmental gathering that often signals authorities plans for the adjacent year. Li Keqiang, China’s outgoing premier, acceptable the yearly GDP maturation people arsenic 5%, the lowest successful astir 30 years. (New York Times $)
- Because the authorities is often cryptic astir its argumentation priorities, it becomes an yearly contented to analyse what words are mentioned the astir successful the premier’s report. This year, “stability,” “food,” and “energy” took halfway stage. (Nikkei Asia $)
- Some governmental representatives travel from the tech industry, and it’s communal (and permissible) for them to marque argumentation recommendations that are favorable to their ain concern interests. I called it “the Chinese benignant of lobbying” successful a study past year. (Protocol)
2. Wuxi, a second-tier metropolis successful eastbound China, announced that it has deliberately destroyed a cardinal pieces of idiosyncratic data, arsenic portion of its process of decommissioning pandemic surveillance systems. (CNN)
3. Diversifying from manufacturing successful China, Foxconn plans to summation accumulation successful India from 6 cardinal iPhones a twelvemonth to 20 million, and to triple the fig of workers to 100,000 by 2024. (Wall Street Journal $)
4. Chinese diplomats are being idolized similar pop-culture celebrities by young fans connected societal media. (What’s connected Weibo $)
5. China is readying connected creating a caller authorities bureau that has concentrated authorization connected assorted data-related issues, anonymous sources said. (Wall Street Journal $)
6. Activists and investors are criticizing Volkswagen aft its CEO toured the company’s factories successful Xinjiang and said helium didn’t spot immoderate motion of forced labor. (Reuters $)
7. Wuling, the Chinese tiny-EV marque that outsold Tesla successful 2021, has recovered its archetypal overseas marketplace successful Indonesia, and its cars person go the astir fashionable prime of EV there. (Rest of World)
8. The US authorities added 37 much Chinese companies, immoderate successful genetics probe and unreality computing, to its commercialized blacklist. (Reuters $)
Lost successful translation
As startups swarm to make the Chinese mentation of ChatGPT, Chinese work Leiphone made an infographic comparing personage founders successful China to find who’s astir apt to triumph the race. The investigation takes into information 4 dimensions: world estimation and influence, acquisition moving with firm engineers, resourcefulness wrong the Chinese governmental and concern ecosystem, and proclaimed involvement successful joining the AI chatbot arms race.
The 2 winners of the investigation are Wang Xiaochuan, the CEO of Chinese hunt motor Sogou, and Lu Qi, a erstwhile enforcement astatine Microsoft and Baidu. Wang has embedded himself profoundly successful the circles of Tsinghua University (China’s apical engineering school) and Tencent, making it imaginable for him to assemble a prima squad quickly. Meanwhile, Lu’s acquisition moving connected Microsoft’s Bing and Baidu’s self-driving portion makes him highly relevant. Plus, Lu is present the caput of Y Combinator China and has idiosyncratic connections to Sam Altman, the CEO of OpenAI and the erstwhile president of Y Combinator.
One much thing
Recently, a video went viral successful China that shows a operator kneeling successful beforehand of his electrical conveyance to scan his face. An app successful the car strategy required the operator to verify his individuality done facial recognition, and since there’s nary camera wrong the car, the exterior camera connected the beforehand of the car was the lone option.
