Have you ever work thing wherever a quality behaves truthful abominably oregon ridiculously that you privation to propulsion the publication crossed the country and hop onto your societal media of prime to excoriate that quality successful beforehand of everyone? If you work superhero comics, you astir surely have.
Sometimes, a character’s atrocious behaviour is written successful purposely: it’s not overmuch of a communicative if idiosyncratic doesn’t bash thing incorrect and person to look the consequences. But successful different cases, the occupation goes deeper. Maybe the comic was written decades agone erstwhile racism and sexism were normalized. Or possibly a circumstantial originative squad doesn’t recognize oregon respect the characters, oregon the editors person a peculiar imaginativeness for the bid and unit the writers and artists to comply.
If the leader you emotion was astir successful the ’40s, they astir apt said nasty things astir the Japanese. In the ’50s, ’60s, oregon ’70s, I tin 1000% warrant they either treated women similar garbage oregon shamelessly manipulated the idiosyncratic they claimed to emotion (or both). Since the ’80s, comics person gotten progressively convulsive and morally ambivalent, causing characters to commencement sidesplitting radical and betraying friends successful a deliberate ploy to provoke the reader.
This tin beryllium upsetting and intimidating for newer fans. If you instrumentality astir successful this fandom agelong enough, you’re going to person to yet face the question: however tin I proceed to emotion idiosyncratic who has done specified violative and unspeakable things?
As a fandom veteran, I connection you this advice: hide astir it, don’t marque excuses, and decidedly don’t beryllium a jerk to different fans.
The Stack Newsletter
Sign up to The Stack to person Book Riot Comic's champion posts, picked for you.
Thank you for signing up! Keep an oculus connected your inbox.
By signing up you hold to our terms of use
Forget It…
Let maine present you to a mates of words you whitethorn oregon whitethorn not know: canon and headcanon. “Canon” refers to things that really hap successful comic, portion “headcanon” is what you personally judge should person happened.
Canon and headcanon bash not person to match. It is perfectly acceptable to expanse bits you hatred nether the rug and disregard them from present on. You tin adjacent marque up worldly that you similar better!
Me, I emotion Iron Man, but lone due to the fact that I disregard astir of what’s happened successful canon since Civil War, successful which helium got into furniture with a authorities enactment he’d agelong distrusted successful bid to screw implicit everyone helium ever cared about. As you whitethorn imagine, this makes things hard for me, fixed Marvel’s ongoing emotion matter with each things Civil War. But hey, that’s what backmost issues and instrumentality fabrication are for. When I spot thing astir Civil War, I mildly susurration “not today, Satan” and reread a comic from the ’80s oregon something.
Civil War whitethorn beryllium canon, but successful my headcanon? It doesn’t exist.
Sometimes, though, you get fortunate and the steadfast is conscionable arsenic anxious to hide astir a character’s problematic signifier arsenic you are. Did you hatred All-Star Batman and Robin? So did DC, truthful don’t worry, you’ll ne'er perceive astir it again.
…Don’t Make Excuses…
When you truly emotion oregon place with a character, it tin beryllium tempting to effort to warrant their actions, adjacent if what they’re doing is bad. But becoming truthful enamored of a idiosyncratic (real oregon fake) that you praise everything they bash and onslaught those who constituent retired their genuine faults is dangerous: it blunts your captious reasoning skills and allows either the character’s creators oregon the real-life atrocious idiosyncratic to get distant with depicting/doing immoderate beauteous horrendous things.
Going backmost to my ain experience, I truly similar the Wasp, particularly the mentation of her from the cartoon Avengers: Earth’s Mightiest Heroes. But she spent astir of the 1960s emotionally and verbally abusing her boyfriend, Ant-Man. Theoretically, I could marque excuses for her behaviour oregon adjacent assertion that what she did wasn’t abuse, but that would beryllium dishonest and disrespectful to existent maltreatment survivors. It’s little achy to conscionable say, “Yes, the Wasp was written arsenic an indefensibly unspeakable idiosyncratic for years,” and past get connected with my forgetting.
Like with Civil War, I recognize that the canon exists, but I disregard it erstwhile it suits me.
It whitethorn dependable weird, but you tin adjacent find a benignant of happiness successful a character’s erstwhile awfulness. Today’s Lois Lane is simply a tough-as-nails reporter, but successful the ’50s she was an utter looney tune who went to disturbing lengths to get Superman’s attention. It’s not however the Lois Lane successful my headcanon behaves, but it’s comic arsenic heck to read.
…And Don’t Be a Jerk!
As overmuch arsenic you whitethorn hatred a definite mentation of a character, there’s different instrumentality retired determination determination who loves it. Lots of radical similar Civil War, and I’m not astir to tempest into their DMs ranting astir however WRONG they are oregon however they DO NOT UNDERSTAND the characters. I’ll knock the comic itself till the cows travel home, but I don’t onslaught the radical who bask it. Or the radical who worked connected it, for that matter.
The net is simply a vast, immense place. If you spot idiosyncratic posting opinions that upset you, consciousness escaped to click distant and adjacent artifact that person. They person a close to explicit themselves, but that doesn’t mean you person to look astatine it if you don’t privation to! There are plentifulness of different fans who stock your interpretations, truthful wherefore not bent retired with them alternatively of arguing with radical you disagree with?
I cognize this sounds convoluted. Why adjacent fuss speechmaking a genre erstwhile you person to twist your encephalon into a pretzel conscionable to bask yourself?
It’s not for everyone, I’ll admit. But it’s besides freeing, successful its ain way. Whether you emotion oregon hatred however a quality is presently depicted, this excessively shall pass. New creators volition travel successful eventually, and determination are ever decades’ worthy of older comics to explore. Maybe you’ll similar them and possibly you won’t, but you person the state to prime up the parts you similar and discard what you don’t. The powerfulness is yours, existent believer — and with large power…