'Irrelevant': Clubs facing uncomfortable reality

1 year ago 73

What's much important, the agelong word wellness of footballers oregon a crippled of rugby league?

I'm struggling to wrapper my caput astir this ongoing debate. It's sparked up again pursuing the opening circular of the National Rugby League, fixed we've got several coaches blowing up astir the autarkic doc successful the Bunker, who has the powerfulness to region a subordinate from the tract if they're showing signs of concussion.

Adam O'Brien and Kalyn Ponga questioned the determination connected Friday nighttime erstwhile the Knights five-eighth was taken from the tract with 10 minutes to go and the crippled successful the balance. Keep successful caput Ponga has a past of head-knocks, truthful there's a request to err connected the broadside of caution alternatively than chasing contention points.

It's irrelevant whether the subordinate thinks he's fine, Ponga stayed down and determination was capable grounds for the autarkic doc to person him removed and examined by the club's aesculapian unit connected the touchline.

These aesculapian professionals aren't supporting the teams and attempting to power the result, they've been enactment successful the Bunker for a crushed and I'll instrumentality the informed sentiment of a doc implicit a manager oregon subordinate each time of the week.

Under the caller guidelines, the autarkic doc tin instantly regularisation a subordinate retired of a lucifer if they show class 1 symptoms, specified arsenic nonaccomplishment of consciousness, failing to support oneself erstwhile falling and unsteadiness connected their feet.

Previously, players could beryllium ruled retired of a lucifer lone if a nine doc observed class 1 signs either unrecorded oregon connected a sideline reappraisal monitor, oregon the subordinate failed a caput wounded appraisal successful a 15-minute model aft being taken from the field.

The caller strategy is designed to region the subordinate rapidly and forestall immoderate further harm to the brain, yet we're questioning the decisions being made by autarkic doctors who person entree to instant replays and assorted camera angles astatine Redfern.

They besides person the vantage of a quiescent country implicit a manager barking astatine them down the 2-way vigor successful the dressing country to find retired if the subordinate has passed the HIA and volition beryllium backmost connected the field. If you were to person the doc connected the sideline, ideate the unit of looking astatine replays with the deafening cheers of the assemblage successful the background.

It would beryllium similar driving done highest hr portion listening to dense metallic music.

Canberra manager Ricky Stuart was asked astir it connected Saturday nighttime aft the nonaccomplishment to North Queensland and 'Sticky' pointed the digit astatine the NRL and RLPA for not trusting the 17 coaches. However, it's not a substance of trust, it's the league acting connected its work of care.

Wayne Bennett wants the NRL to marque the clubs much accountable with the Dolphins manager suggesting, "We don't request a doc successful the container … I tin recognize wherefore (it was introduced) but I don't spot the request for it successful the archetypal place."

"Instead of taking the brushed options and pandering to clubs who bash the incorrect happening … the clubs person to ain it" Bennett said.

I disagree.

It's nary longer a substance of the clubs owning subordinate safety, everyone has to enactment unneurotic oregon we won't person a crippled successful 10 years' time. We're already seeing people actions successful different codes astir the satellite and we can't spend the aforesaid successful the NRL.

The interaction sports similar rugby league, rugby national and boxing were summoned to a Senate enquiry past week successful Canberra to explicate what they're doing to woody with players who endure repeated caput knocks and concussion.

Concussion and CTE is simply a existent menace for these young men who play 1 of the astir brutal interaction sports successful the world. We've got legends of the crippled and erstwhile players who can't retrieve the names of their household members due to the fact that they kept playing with repeated caput knocks.

There needs to beryllium immoderate position here. Would you similar to beryllium down with your household aboriginal successful beingness and beryllium capable to place your ain children, oregon criticise an autarkic doc for taking you disconnected a shot tract due to the fact that you're suffering a imaginable concussion?

I'm atrocious to say, the days of the gladiatorial battles and large hits betwixt the likes of Mark 'Spud' Carroll and Paul 'The Chief' Harragon are over.

It's clip for everyone to aftermath up and realise the threats to these interaction sports are concussion and aboriginal litigation.

If we don't dainty it seriously, we'll extremity up watching interaction football.

Let maine cognize your thoughts by sending done an email to the WWOS Radio amusement connected 2GB by clicking connected this link; https://form.jotform.co/70601482897867

Wide World of Sports Radio is heard from 6pm AEDT connected 2GB 873am with Mark Levy and co-hosts Shane Flanagan (Monday), Paul Gallen (Tuesday), Brad Fittler (Wednesday), Ken Sutcliffe (Thursday) and Mark Riddell (Friday).

For a regular dose of the champion of the breaking quality and exclusive contented from Wide World of Sports, subscribe to our newsletter by clicking here!