Starter homes have become a 'fairy tale,' so Americans are finding other ways to own

In 2020, Amanda Schneider was forced retired of her rental portion adjacent Nashville, Tennessee, erstwhile her landlord sold the property.

Tired of renting, she decided she wanted to ain and pitched an antithetic idea: co-buying a location with her 2 roommates.

The much they thought astir it, the much it made sense. The 3 women, each successful their 20s, were adjacent — "like siblings" — and splitting the costs afforded them a location they couldn't person purchased connected their own.

Schneider and her roommates aren't unsocial successful uncovering originative ways to concern their archetypal location amid surging prices. Co-buying with friends is an progressively fashionable idea, arsenic the fig of co-buyers with antithetic past names has accrued by 31% since 2019, according to astir caller information from ATTOM, a spot information provider.

This, and different antithetic lodging situations, are mostly retired of necessity: U.S. median location prices have surged 33% since January 2020, from $329,000 to $436,800. To spend the monthly owe outgo connected a median-priced home, homebuyers request to gain much than $100,000, good supra the U.S. median household income of $70,784, according to Census Bureau data. 

And the "starter home" — typically, a modestly priced two-bedroom location with less amenities, specified arsenic little retention abstraction oregon nary backyard — has go exceedingly rare, but successful a fistful of markets.

"The thought of a 'starter home' has go much of a fairy tale," says Denis Smykalov, a Florida-based existent property broker astatine Wolsen Real Estate.

As a result, "it's go progressively challenging for first-time buyers to find an affordable entry-level spot that meets their needs," says Smykalov. "Now, galore first-time buyers are forced to prevention for a longer time, oregon see alternate options."

Here's a look astatine however a fistful of radical are navigating a pugnacious lodging market, from buying tiny homes to renting retired portion of their spot to sharing the costs with friends.

It didn't instrumentality agelong for Schneider and her roommates, Stephanie Vandergrift and Kathy Keel, to determine to divided the outgo of buying a house. They knew they inactive wanted to unrecorded unneurotic and each stock the aforesaid mindset, Schneider says.

"The 3 of america are precise career-focused and we're not funny successful matrimony oregon having children."

By owning a location together, they could perpetrate to thing "more semipermanent wherever it's besides an investment," says Schneider. Plus, they'd person much power implicit renovations and repairs, the costs of which would beryllium easier to screen with 3 radical paying.

After a fewer weeks of searching, the roommates recovered a two-story detached ceramic location connected 1.25 acres of onshore successful Gallatin, Tennessee, for $315,000. The location features 3 bedrooms, a finished store with a country supra it, a downstairs bureau and a ample gait with a occurrence pit.

They made a down outgo of 10% and took retired a owe for the remaining costs, which they divided evenly. Other expenses, including utilities and repairs, are divided evenly arsenic well. If 1 of them decides to determination out, the different 2 roommates person a program to bargain retired their stock of ownership.

"As a azygous purchaser, I don't deliberation I couldn't person gotten thing arsenic nice," says Schneider. "With 3 incomes, it broadens the anticipation of what we could get, and we genuinely bask surviving unneurotic arsenic a portion of roommates."

It's been a astute fiscal determination too. As an investment, the location has "skyrocketed" successful worth since Schneider and her roommates moved successful 3 years ago, she says.

However, buying a location with friends isn't for everyone. It's "essential" that you're connected the aforesaid leafage with your co-buyers, Schneider says, truthful that "you enactment unneurotic arsenic a unit, alternatively than conscionable 3 abstracted radical surviving successful the aforesaid home."

While they qualified for a larger mortgage, they acceptable a spending headdress of astir $325,000. They wanted to support monthly owe payments debased to guarantee that 2 roommates could screen the costs if 1 of them decided to determination out.

In 2019, 25-year-old Vadim Yuryev and his wife, Annette, had capable wealth to acquisition a starter location for their young household successful Spokane, Washington, wherever helium was raised. But helium besides wanted a cash-generating spot that could assistance screen the monthly costs.

The solution: location hacking, which is erstwhile homeowners partially oregon wholly screen their owe by renting retired portion of the property, whether that's a country oregon a detached unit, similar a excavation location oregon backyard cabin.

"I went with a duplex due to the fact that determination is much worth successful it," says Yuryev, present 29. "It isn't that overmuch much costly than a house, but you get 2 units you tin rent retired for a batch much than the mortgage."

Yuryev bought the duplex for $235,000, which was financed with a 15% down outgo and a $200,000 mortgage. He and his woman spent different $35,000 connected renovations for 1 fractional of the property, which is wherever the mates lived portion renting retired the different half.

In 2021, Yuryev took vantage of debased involvement rates and refinanced the mortgage, lowering the complaint from 3.99% to 2.875%. This brought monthly owe payments — which included spot taxes and security — down from $1,329 to $1,217.

Most of that was offset by the $1,000 they received successful monthly rental income. All told, Yuryev lone paid astir $500 successful monthly lodging costs to screen the remainder of the owe positive utilities.

The mates moved retired of the duplex to a bigger rental portion successful January 2023. The duplex is simply a cash-generating spot now, with some units presently rented retired for full monthly gross of $2,800.

Despite the income, determination were downsides to renting retired portion of the property, Yuryev found. While renters tin assistance bring down costs, you inactive request a batch of currency upfront, particularly for older buildings, helium says. To screen the costs of repairs and imaginable vacancies successful his rental unit, Yuryev maintained a currency reserve of $15,000 portion helium was an owner-occupant. 

Eventually, the Yuryevs program to bargain different home, but they're waiting retired the existent property marketplace for present owed to precocious involvement rates and the anticipation that location prices successful Spokane volition chill disconnected astatine immoderate point.

When her 18-year matrimony ended successful 2018, Jen Gressett recovered herself priced retired of the existent property marketplace successful Boulder, Colorado.

She had been surviving successful a four-bedroom, 3,000-square-foot location with her then-husband and their 2 kids, but arsenic a azygous income earner successful a lodging marketplace wherever median location prices were implicit $600,000, buying a regular-sized location connected her ain wasn't an option.

One mode astir the sky-high prices: simply ain little home. 

A tiny location — often portable and little than 400 quadrate feet — costs an mean of $52,000, which is 87% cheaper than a regular home, according to a 2022 Porch.com survey. 

"I looked into apartments, since that's what astir radical bash erstwhile they get divorced," she says. "But it was truthful costly — a two-bedroom was astir $2,000 a month."

Gressett was alert of tiny houses, but it wasn't until she saw immoderate of the nicer ones that it made much consciousness arsenic a spot to live. "I could spot myself surviving successful one. And it didn't look similar a compromise astatine all," she says. 

In 2021, Gressett, moved into a custom-made tiny location that runs her $725 per month. "Because I'm connected a azygous income, paying lone $725 per period gives maine bid of mind," says Gressett. "It allows maine to prevention much and beryllium amended prepared should immoderate unexpected fiscal needs arise."

The tiny location has a quartz countertop kitchen, soaker tub and a king-sized bed. Her location is portable, too. "It's fundamentally a conveyance — my location has a licence plate."

Overall, Gressett spent $175,000 to physique her tiny home, including a prefabricated ammunition structure, labour and worldly costs. She paid for it utilizing $85,000 from the merchantability of her erstwhile home, arsenic good arsenic a idiosyncratic indebtedness of $90,000 from a adjacent friend.

That said, she says she made a batch of mistakes on the way. The biggest one: Hiring her archetypal builder, who wasn't decently certified and took excessively agelong to physique the home. "He had the incorrect roofing, and one of the windows wholly fell out," she says. "So galore things had to redone, and I had to wage for them to beryllium redone." 

But it's been a astute determination overall. "For me, the champion portion of tiny location surviving is it takes mode little clip to cleanable than a regular home," says Gressett. "I tin get everything cleanable successful astir an hour, which gives maine much clip to beryllium retired doing things I love, similar way moving oregon hiking."

Gressett has afloat embraced the tiny location lifestyle, sharing proposal and tips to implicit 160,000 followers connected her Instagram account.

"Thinking long-term, surviving successful a tiny location semipermanent benignant of works," she says. "If my kids determine to permission Colorado oregon whatever, I could conscionable determination my location to travel them to wherever they extremity up."

DON'T MISS: Want to beryllium smarter and much palmy with your money, enactment & life? Sign up for our caller newsletter!

Get CNBC's free Warren Buffett Guide to Investing, which distills the billionaire's No. 1 champion portion of proposal for regular investors, do's and don'ts, and 3 cardinal investing principles into a wide and elemental guidebook.