2 years ago
163
If you don’t cognize astir Joyce Carol Oates’s tweet history, I envy you. Suffice to say, she’s notorious for going viral with immoderate genuinely mystifying blistery takes. In her latest example, she claims that “fantasy arsenic a genre is fundamentally YA” and misrepresents Ted Chiang arsenic saying that sci-fi is “impersonal, ne'er ‘magical'” and phantasy is “personal, character-driven, ‘magical.'”
Of course, publication Twitter was not going to fto that stand, and aft the archetypal daze and joking subsided, they began discussing the real differences betwixt subject fabrication and fantasy. From pointed commentary connected cardinal problems successful SFF publishing and fandom to jokes astir actors that play successful some spheres, determination was a immense scope of responses utilizing this format.
I was watching this unfold with rapt attention, due to the fact that I emotion a bookish Twitter meme. In lawsuit you aren’t swimming successful the depths of publication Twitter similar I am, I’ve collected immoderate of the champion responses below.
If you privation to cognize the existent quality betwixt sci-fi and fantasy, you person to travel the money.
Lemme wide it up for you. Sci-fi is erstwhile your currency is called credits, and phantasy is erstwhile it's called coin.
— dc guevara 🗡💋 (@dcgrodz) September 23, 2022
Book Deals Newsletter
Sign up for our Book Deals newsletter and get up to 80% disconnected books you really privation to read.
Thank you for signing up! Keep an oculus connected your inbox.
By signing up you hold to our terms of use
Interesting however determination seems to ever beryllium a crushed speculative fabrication worlds are truthful white.
Fantasy is erstwhile Black radical are told they’re historically inaccurate, sci-fi is erstwhile Black radical are told “it’s woke garbage” they exist
— ✨Strix U's Sailor Scout Austin✨ (@sailorsctaustin) September 24, 2022
Despite often erasing the radical of color, SFF worlds inactive negociate to due different cultures.
Look, we each privation fancy pointed ears, nary substance the setting. Why did humans get stuck with these boring rounded ones?
If this tweet speaks to you, mightiness I involvement you successful immoderate alien romance books?
fantasy is erstwhile you fuck elves. sci fi is erstwhile you fuck aliens
— nora, resurrected (@NoraReed) September 24, 2022
You didn’t deliberation we were done talking astir racism and antisemitism successful SFF, did you?
It’s conscionable that simple.
no nary no, phantasy is erstwhile the exertion the characters usage is magic and sci-fi is erstwhile the magic the characters usage is technology
— ROP Spoilers | Lord Liar Lunatic of the Rings (@LLLOfTheRings) September 22, 2022
Oops, much bigoted SFF tropes.
Fantasy is erstwhile abdominous radical are greedy corrupt evil royalty and subject fabrication is erstwhile abdominous radical are greedy corrupt evil royalty, but successful space.
— Meg Elison (@megelison) September 23, 2022
Either way, you can’t spell wrong.
What a coincidence that I’m speechmaking a publication called The Future is Disabled arsenic we speak. I highly urge picking that up alternatively of SFF books that diagnostic ableist tropes similar this.
Lemme wide it up for you. Sci-fi is erstwhile disabilities awesome societal collapse, and phantasy is erstwhile they awesome motivation failure.
— The Tweedy Mutant ♿🏳️⚧️🏳️🌈 (@the_tweedy) September 23, 2022
What astir if there’s a section dedicated to a nutrient truck?
Fantasy is erstwhile there's an full section dedicated to describing food, sci-fi is erstwhile there's an full section dedicated to describing transportation.
— Carly Lane-Perry (@carlylane) September 23, 2022
It’s subtle.
Sci fi is erstwhile Patrick Stewart sits successful a seat giving orders; Fantasy is erstwhile Patrick Stewart sits successful a seat giving orders… pic.twitter.com/IE7WZYSSdC
— Classical Studies Memes for Hellenistic Teens (@CSMFHT) September 24, 2022
As idiosyncratic who lives not acold from Vancouver, this 1 truly got to me.
Fantasy is erstwhile it's filmed successful a wood connected the outskirts of Vancouver. Sci-fi is erstwhile it's filmed successful a stone quarry connected the outskirts of Vancouver.
— zeddy (@Zeddary) September 24, 2022
And, of course, there’s ever the food factor.
And determination you person it! In lawsuit you had immoderate lingering questions, present you truly cognize the quality betwixt sci-fi and fantasy. If you were hoping for immoderate superior answers, you mightiness privation to cheque retired this explainer station astir speculative fiction. And portion you’re here, wherefore not instrumentality a look astatine the Most Influential Science Fiction Books of All Time and the Most Influential Fantasy Books of All Time?
English (US) ·