The weird truth about calories and why food labels get them so wrong

B Christopher/Alamy

WHEN you are navigating the analyzable satellite of nutrition, the calorie feels mercifully simple. A straightforward measurement of the vigor successful our food, calories beryllium astatine the bosom of accepted value power advice. Consume excessively many, oregon neglect to pain enough, and you volition enactment connected weight. Want to slim down? Eat little and determination more. As the saying goes, “a calorie is simply a calorie is simply a calorie”. Dig a small deeper, however, and you find it isn’t that simple.

This thought of the assemblage arsenic a furnace and nutrient arsenic its substance was popularised by Wilbur Atwater successful the 19th century. He deduced that determination are 3 main components, oregon macronutrients, with which we tin cipher the calorie contented of immoderate food: protein and carbohydrates incorporate 4 calories per gram, portion fats incorporate 9. Combine these and the effect informs the calorie contented connected nutrient labels everywhere.

But deliberation astir however nutrient is consumed and you deed your archetypal problem. Take an orange, says Giles Yeo, a geneticist astatine the University of Cambridge and writer of Why Calories Don’t Count. An orangish is chiefly carbohydrate, oregon sugar. “When you portion orangish juice, your assemblage volition sorb the sweetener [quickly] due to the fact that determination is nary digestion required,” says Yeo. Eat orangish segments, however, and it takes vigor for the digestive strategy to enactment connected the fibre and extract the sugar. “Physiologically, your assemblage does wholly antithetic things with it, with precisely the aforesaid calorie hit,” says Yeo.

Orange foodstuff causes a much accelerated spike successful humor sweetener levels than the orangish segments, for example, and regular surges successful humor sweetener …