This Fidelity manager has crushed the S&P 500 since 1989—here's his advice for investors

There isn't a Hall of Fame for communal money managers. But if determination was, Joel Tillinghast would beryllium getting buzz arsenic a first-ballot inductee.

Since his fund, Fidelity Low-Priced Stock, launched successful December 1989, investors person enjoyed an annualized full instrumentality of astir 13%. That smashes the astir 9% turned successful by the fund's benchmark Russell 2000 index, which tracks the show of small-company stocks, and is good up of the S&P 500 index's conscionable implicit 10% instrumentality implicit the aforesaid period.

The quality successful show is bigger than it seems. Had you invested $1,000 successful Low-Priced Stock connected Tillinghast's archetypal day, you'd presently person much than $57,000, according to information provided by Morningstar Direct. The aforesaid concern successful an S&P 500 scale money would beryllium worthy astir $25,000.

Tillinghast picked up 3 co-managers successful 2016 and 2017, and 2 of them — Morgan Peck and Sam Chamovitz — volition instrumentality the helm erstwhile Tillinghast steps down astatine twelvemonth end. They volition nary uncertainty look to proceed a strategy of picking undervalued tiny and midsize institution stocks they judge tin present outsize semipermanent returns to shareholders.

In the meantime, Tillinghast chatted with CNBC Make It astir lessons successful stock-picking, keys to semipermanent investing occurrence and the changing scenery for retail investors.

CNBC Make It: Your fund's mandate has changed immoderate implicit the years, but the attack to picking stocks has remained the same. How would you picture your strategy?

Tillinghast: We look for stocks that commercialized astatine a discount to their intrinsic value. And we thin to hunt successful the places that are slightest successful the nationalist eye. So they're astir apt not the things that are making up the pb stories of CNBC oregon The Wall Street Journal. They're hidden successful the backmost pages.

Those would beryllium tiny and mid-cap stocks [those with tiny and mean marketplace capitalizations], domestically and globally. Anything that is benignant of neglected capable that it mightiness beryllium undervalued.

How bash you specify a worth stock? What makes a definite institution undervalued?

In a cleanable world, what I'm looking for are companies wherever net crook into cash, which tin beryllium returned to shareholders, and looking for companies wherever it's not unsafe oregon ridiculous to deliberation astir what the net powerfulness volition beryllium successful 5 years oregon 10 years. The money is simply a semipermanent focused fund, due to the fact that worth comes retired implicit the agelong term.

How bash you differentiate yourself from different small-company banal funds, galore of which thin to hew intimately to the benchmark index?

If you commencement with the Russell 2000 benchmark, we're antithetic successful that we person a agelong process of mid-cap stocks, and adjacent a fewer precise ample headdress stocks. One of the astir notable features is that we person a batch of planetary tiny caps.

Japan is simply a peculiar country of interest, and Sam Chamovitz, who's fractional of the squad that's taking implicit the fund, spent respective years moving successful Japan. And truthful we person the vantage of much attraction to smaller [Japanese] companies that are not good followed by brokers, oregon anyone for that matter.

You've helmed the money since 1989. How has your attack to investing evolved since then?

I deliberation anybody who doesn't alteration is missing the point. The amusive happening astir investing is you're perpetually learning — sometimes by losing money, sometimes by making wealth erstwhile you didn't expect to. The ones wherever you suffer wealth thin to instrumentality with you.

There's truthful overmuch much accusation done quality media and Wall Street. I deliberation it's a bully happening each this accusation is retired there, but the atrocious quality is radical person truthful overmuch short-term information, truthful galore information points, that they are distracted from the indispensable enactment of reasoning astir the concern quality. They're spending little clip reasoning astir the barriers to entry, the prime of management, whether a concern is doing thing that customers deliberation is special.

The different large alteration is much concern models spell away. If you didn't cognize astir the internet, you'd person thought that each cultured household would person an encyclopedia and a soft successful their house. Today, they person neither. Their machine does it for them. Business models are changing due to the fact that of technology, and that is different. And truthful idiosyncratic who is trying to look retired 5 years has to prosecute with that.

What's a acquisition person you learned from a large winner?

I bought Monster Beverage — astatine the clip they were Hansen's Natural and were a foodstuff portion institution — due to the fact that I liked that they were trying an vigor drink. I similar companies that effort a batch of experiments. They whitethorn not ever work, but they bash effort a batch of things. And I deliberation Monster is precise innovative that way.

Tillinghast bought successful 2001 astatine astir $4 per stock — accounting for splits, that's much similar 4 cents a share. Now it trades for $58.

Warren Buffett — possibly the world's astir celebrated banal picker and worth capitalist — tells retail investors to gravitate toward scale funds. Do you agree?

You person to deliberation astir wherever you person an vantage and what you're trying to bash successful the market.

If you don't person immoderate vantage successful assessing value; if you don't person immoderate vantage successful telling whether things are overmuch amended than radical think; and if you're not peculiarly bully astatine imagining what the maturation volition beryllium implicit 3 to 5 years, a passive money is close for you.

Even progressive investors should deliberation astir what is it that they bash that adds worth beyond the index.

Still, determination are communal money managers similar you who tin and person beaten indexes implicit agelong periods. Clearly it's important to look astatine way record, but beyond that, however tin I take a money with a worthwhile manager?

You should look for 1 that intelligibly articulates what it is that they're doing that's special.

If I speech with [Fidelity Contrafund manager] Will Danoff, helium tells me, "I privation the best-in-class successful increasing industries." He wants a precise abbreviated database of the champion absorption teams that are champion positioned successful increasing industries.

I americium looking for stocks that are reasonably undervalued hoping that they're not conscionable 10% undervalued. I privation a batch much undervaluation than that — particularly successful the fullness of clip wherever you travel backmost 5 years aboriginal and say, "Oh, it truly was worthy a batch much than you paid for it."

I would look for a money wherever the manager intelligibly articulates that. If they say, "I bash a small of this, a small of that" — no. Put it successful the scale money oregon find a amended manager.

What's your proposal for young investors? How tin they put similar Joel Tillinghast?

Think astir your quality and what works for you. My patience is an plus for me, but would beryllium a full liability for a momentum investor. For immoderate people, there's truthful overmuch aggravation and interest that putting it successful scale funds is the champion approach.

To put similar me, instrumentality a agelong view. Think astir what net volition beryllium successful 5 years. Take a portion to see your possibilities. If you've got a genuinely fantastic semipermanent communicative that is genuinely undervalued, marque it bigger — not needfully 20% of your portfolio, but it's bully to marque it important if you deliberation it's big.

It would astir apt person a little [price-to-earnings ratio] than the market, precocious escaped currency travel yields [a measurement of a company's escaped currency versus its marketplace value], and it would astir apt person growth, due to the fact that the institution was doing thing peculiar that clients truly liked.

I'm comparing terms and worth each the time. I deliberation tons of investors don't truly bash that. You person to cognize to beryllium patient, and to person supra mean patience erstwhile you deliberation thing bully is happening.

This interrogation has been edited for brevity and clarity.

DON'T MISS: Want to beryllium smarter and much palmy with your money, enactment & life? Sign up for our caller newsletter!

 Get CNBC's free Warren Buffett Guide to Investing, which distills the billionaire's No. 1 champion portion of proposal for regular investors, do's and don'ts, and 3 cardinal investing principles into a wide and elemental guidebook.

CHECK OUT: 3 ways Warren Buffett’s protégé invests similar him—and wherever she and the billionaire differ