TikTok CEO set to face a grilling in House hearing. Lawmakers also have tough questions to answer

TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew volition look a pugnacious assemblage connected Thursday erstwhile helium testifies earlier the House Energy and Commerce Committee portion his institution is connected the brink of a imaginable prohibition successful the U.S.

Although TikTok is the 1 successful the blistery spot connected Thursday, the proceeding volition besides rise existential questions for the U.S. authorities regarding however it regulates technology. Lawmakers admit that the concerns implicit wide information postulation and the quality to power what accusation consumers spot widen acold beyond TikTok alone. U.S. tech platforms including Meta's Facebook and Instagram, Google's YouTube, Twitter and Snap's Snapchat person raised akin fears for lawmakers and users.

That means that portion trying to recognize whether TikTok tin efficaciously support U.S. consumers nether a Chinese owner, lawmakers volition besides person to grapple with however champion to code user harms crossed the industry.

Conversations with lawmakers, legislature aides and extracurricular experts up of the proceeding uncover the hard enactment the authorities needs to locomotion to support U.S. nationalist information portion avoiding excessive enactment against a azygous app and violating First Amendment rights.

There's small appetite successful Washington to judge the imaginable risks that TikTok's ownership by Chinese institution ByteDance poses to U.S. nationalist security. Congress has already banned the app connected authorities devices and immoderate states person made akin moves.

The interagency sheet tasked with reviewing nationalist information risks stemming from ByteDance's ownership has threatened a ban if the institution won't merchantability its involvement successful the app.

Still, an outright prohibition raises its ain concerns, perchance missing the wood for the trees.

"If members absorption solely connected the imaginable of a prohibition oregon a forced merchantability without addressing immoderate of the much pervasive issues, peculiarly those facing children and younger users, shared by TikTok and U.S.-based societal media companies, I deliberation that would beryllium a mistake," Rep. Lori Trahan, D-Mass., a committee member, told CNBC successful an interrogation connected Tuesday. Trahan said members should inquire astir nationalist information risks of the app, but those questions should beryllium substantive.

Rep. Gus Bilirakis, R-Fla., who chairs the E&C subcommittee connected innovation, information and commerce, said helium and galore of his colleagues are going into the proceeding unfastened to solutions.

"We person to beryllium open-minded and deliberate," Bilirakis told CNBC successful an interrogation connected Wednesday. "But astatine the aforesaid time, clip is of the essence."

If the authorities moves for a prohibition wherever the concerns could reasonably beryllium mitigated with a little restrictive measure, it could airs First Amendment issues, according to Jameel Jaffer, enforcement manager of the Knight First Amendment Institute astatine Columbia University.

"A prohibition present is successful immoderate ways under-inclusive due to the fact that it would beryllium focused conscionable connected TikTok oregon a tiny fig of platforms, erstwhile successful information galore different platforms are collecting this benignant of accusation arsenic well," Jaffer said. "And successful different ways, it would beryllium over-broad due to the fact that determination are little restrictive ways that the authorities could execute its ends."

While immoderate mightiness wonderment if cutting disconnected Americans' entree to TikTok is truly specified a usurpation of rights, Jaffer said the nationalist should see it successful presumption of the U.S. government's authorization to determine which media Americans tin access.

"It's a bully happening that if the authorities wants to prohibition Americans from accessing overseas media, including overseas societal media... it has to transportation a dense load successful court," Jaffer said.

Many lawmakers hold that the authorities should marque its lawsuit much intelligibly to the American nationalist for wherefore a prohibition is necessary, should it spell that route. The bipartisan RESTRICT Act precocious introduced successful the Senate, for example, would necessitate specified an explanation, to the grade possible, erstwhile the authorities wants to bounds foreign-owned exertion for nationalist information reasons.

Trahan said she could enactment authorities akin to the RESTRICT Act successful the House, which would make a process to mitigate nationalist information risks of technologies from overseas adversary countries, but passing specified a measure would inactive not beryllium enough.

"The connection that I privation folks to perceive is that we cannot spend to walk this authorities oregon thing similar it, ticker the medication prohibition oregon unit the merchantability of TikTok and state triumph successful the combat to rein successful the abuses of ascendant Big Tech companies," Trahan said. "I deliberation the speech close present astir a prohibition surely threatens to fto Big Tech companies disconnected the hook, and it's connected Congress not to autumn into that trap."

Even if the U.S. successfully banned TikTok oregon forced it to rotation disconnected from ByteDance, there's nary mode to cognize for definite that immoderate earlier-collected information is retired of scope of the Chinese government.

"If that divestment would occur, however bash you segregate the codification bases betwixt ByteDance and TikTok?" asked John Lash, who advises clients connected hazard mitigation agreements with the Committee connected Foreign Investment successful the U.S. (CFIUS) but hasn't worked for TikTok oregon ByteDance. "And however is the U.S. authorities going to get comfy that the asset, TikTok, which is hypothetically sold, is escaped of immoderate benignant of backdoor that was either maliciously inserted oregon conscionable weaknesses successful code, errors that hap regularly successful however codification is structured?"

"I deliberation the interest is valid. My large contented is that genie's benignant of retired of the bottle," Eric Cole, a cybersecurity advisor who began his vocation arsenic a hacker for the Central Intelligence Agency, said of the information information fears. "At this point, it's truthful embedded that adjacent if they were palmy successful banning Tiktok altogether, that the harm is done."

Thursday's proceeding volition diagnostic respective lawmakers connected some sides of the aisle calling for broad privateness reform, similar the benignant the sheet passed past year but ne'er made it to the level for a vote.

Those calls service arsenic designation that galore of the concerns astir TikTok, isolated from its ownership by a Chinese company, are shared by different salient tech platforms headquartered successful the U.S.

Both Trahan and Bilirakis mentioned the request for privateness betterment arsenic a much systemic solution to the issues raised by TikTok. Both are particularly acrophobic astir the societal media company's perchance harmful impacts connected children and said they would drill down connected TikTok's protections successful the hearing.

TikTok has touted a analyzable program known arsenic Project Texas to assistance easiness U.S. concerns implicit its ownership. Under the plan, it volition basal its U.S. information operations domestically and let its codification to beryllium reviewed and sent to the app stores by extracurricular parties.

Chew plans to archer Congress that helium powerfully prioritizes the information of users, and peculiarly teens, that TikTok volition firewall U.S. idiosyncratic information from "unauthorized overseas access," it "will not beryllium manipulated by immoderate government" and it volition beryllium transparent and let autarkic monitors to measure its compliance.

Experts and adjacent immoderate lawmakers admit that Project Texas offers a measurement guardant connected immoderate aspects of user extortion they've pushed for successful the tech manufacture much broadly.

"TikTok is successful a truly unsocial presumption close present to instrumentality immoderate affirmative steps connected issues that a batch of apical American companies person fallen down and frankly adjacent regressed connected whether it's protecting kids oregon embracing transparency," Trahan said. While she believes determination are inactive galore questions TikTok needs to reply astir the adequacy of Project Texas, Trahan said she is "hopeful" astir the company's professed "openness to stronger transparency mechanisms."

Lawmakers and aides who spoke with CNBC up of the proceeding emphasized that broad privateness authorities volition beryllium indispensable careless of what enactment is taken against TikTok successful particular. That's however a akin concern successful the aboriginal whitethorn beryllium prevented, and a mode to clasp U.S. companies to higher standards arsenic well.

But fixed national integer privateness protections don't presently exist, Lash said the U.S. should see what it would mean if Project Texas were to spell away.

"In lieu of broad national information privateness regularisation successful the United States, which is needed, does Project Texas springiness the champion disposable enactment close present to support nationalist security?" asked Lash, whose advisory is 1 of a tiny radical of firms with the expertise to counsel the institution connected an statement should a woody spell through. "And does it proceed if ByteDance is forced to divest their interests?"

The program appears to code the issues that lawmakers are acrophobic about, said Lash, but what it can't code are "the theoretical risks astir whitethorn happen, could hap arsenic it relates to the application."

"I would say, based connected what I've seen retired successful the public, it does look to comprehensively code a batch of the existent method risks that whitethorn beryllium arising," helium said.

Still, policymakers look skeptical that Project Texas reaches that bar.

An adjutant for the House Energy and Commerce Committee who was lone authorized to talk connected inheritance told reporters earlier this week that TikTok's hazard mitigation plans were "purely marketing." Another adjutant for the committee noted that adjacent if the U.S. tin beryllium assured the information is secure, it's intolerable to comb done each the existing codification for vulnerabilities.

E&C Chair Cathy McMorris Rodgers, R-Wash., supports a prohibition to code the contiguous risks TikTok poses arsenic good arsenic broad privateness authorities that passed done the committee past Congress to forestall repetition situations, according to E&C aides.

In the lead-up to the hearing, TikTok has turned to creators and users to stock their enactment for the app and assistance lawmakers recognize the unsocial features that marque it an important root of income, unfastened look and acquisition for galore Americans.

On Tuesday, Chew posted a video connected TikTok touting its 150 cardinal monthly progressive users successful the U.S. and appealed to them to permission comments astir what they privation their lawmakers to cognize astir wherefore they emotion TikTok.

The institution has besides recovered an state successful its efforts to combat a prohibition successful Rep. Jamaal Bowman, D-N.Y., a TikTok idiosyncratic himself who discovered the powerfulness of the app to physique connections with constituents portion vlogging the lengthy Speaker of the House election.

On Wednesday, Bowman held a property league with dozens of creators, opposing the prohibition and saying rhetoric astir the app is simply a benignant of "red scare" pushed chiefly by Republicans. He said helium supports broad authorities addressing privateness issues crossed the industry, alternatively than singling retired 1 platform. Bowman noted lawmakers haven't received a bipartisan legislature briefing from the medication connected nationalist information risks stemming from TikTok.

"Let's not person a dishonest conversation," Bowman said. "Let's not beryllium racist toward China and explicit our xenophobia erstwhile it comes to TikTok. Because American companies person done tremendous harm to American people."

Reps. Mark Pocan, D-Wisc., and Robert Garcia, D-Calif., joined Bowman and the creators, announcing their absorption to a ban. Garcia, who is openly gay, said it's important that young queer creators "are capable to find themselves successful this space, stock accusation and consciousness comfortable, successful immoderate cases travel out."

"Honestly it's done champion connected the TikTok level than immoderate different societal media level that presently exists, surely successful the United States," Garcia said.

Creators astatine the lawsuit connected Wednesday shared the opportunities that TikTok has afforded them that aren't disposable successful the aforesaid mode connected different apps. Several creators who spoke with CNBC said they person different societal media channels but person acold less followers connected them, owed successful portion to the casual discoverability built into TikTok's design.

"I've been connected societal media for astir apt 10 years," said David Ma, a Brooklyn-based contented creator, manager and filmmaker connected TikTok. But it wasn't until helium joined TikTok that his pursuing grew exponentially, to much than 1 cardinal people. "It's fixed maine visibility with radical that are going to fundamentally alteration the trajectory of my career."

Tim Martin, a assemblage shot manager successful North Dakota who posts astir sports connected TikTok to a pursuing of 1 cardinal users, estimated 70% of his income comes from the app. Martin credits the TikTok algorithm with getting his videos successful beforehand of users who genuinely attraction astir what helium has to share, which has helped him turn his pursuing determination acold much than connected Instagram.

But TikTok's effort to displacement the communicative to affirmative stories from creators and users whitethorn inactive autumn level for immoderate lawmakers.

Bilirakis said the strategy is "not resonating with our colleagues. Definitely not with me." That's due to the fact that helium hears different anecdotes astir constituents' encounters with the app that marque him interest for teens' safety.

"I bash deliberation there's a accidental that it whitethorn not needfully person the interaction that TikTok is looking for," said Jasmine Enberg, a societal media expert for Insider Intelligence. "It's much grounds of however firmly entrenched the app is successful the integer lives of Americans, which isn't needfully going to assistance person america lawmakers that TikTok can't beryllium utilized oregon isn't being utilized to power nationalist opinion."

Subscribe to CNBC connected YouTube.

WATCH: TikTok influencer weighs successful connected imaginable ban