TikTok's potential U.S. ban raises questions for app stores, internet companies and the government

TikTok is astatine risk of being banned successful the U.S. if Chinese genitor ByteDance won't merchantability its stake. Millions of Americans who usage the fashionable video app are near wondering what that means for them.

Some fans of the work whitethorn crook to virtual backstage networks (VPNs) to effort and link to TikTok should a prohibition instrumentality place, a workaround that tin marque it look similar their net transportation is coming from a antithetic country. But that loophole whitethorn not beryllium truthful casual to exploit.

It's not an contented yet, arsenic determination are inactive immoderate ways a TikTok prohibition could beryllium avoided oregon accessed legally successful the U.S. Here are the cardinal things nether consideration.

The Committee connected Foreign Investment successful the U.S. (CFIUS) is the interagency assemblage evaluating nationalist information concerns astir the app to find however to minimize hazard if it continues to run domestically. The radical tin urge to President Joe Biden that ByteDance's 2017 acquisition of Musical.ly, a TikTok precursor, beryllium unwound, forcing a merchantability of those assets.

TikTok has recommended a mitigation program arsenic an alternate to a forced sale. But that's a longshot solution arsenic CFIUS already threatened a ban if ByteDance won't merchantability its stake.

A forced merchantability would beryllium a analyzable step, requiring a years-old transaction to beryllium unwound. The Trump medication pursued that way erstwhile earlier to nary avail. The Chinese authorities would apt oppose it again, but it would request to beryllium cautious successful its protests due to the fact that the bosom of its statement to the U.S. is that TikTok operates independently.

"That would beryllium portion of the calculus and however aggressively China would privation to respond," said Lindsay Gorman, a elder chap for emerging technologies astatine the German Marshall Fund's Alliance for Securing Democracy. Gormany antecedently served arsenic a elder advisor astatine the Biden White House.

Should the U.S. prohibition TikTok, the mechanics connected what happens from determination get murky. Oracle is the cloud hosting service for each of TikTok usage successful the U.S. Internet work providers similar Comcast (NBC Universal's genitor company) and Verizon nonstop postulation to extremity users. And the app stores controlled by Apple and Google are the superior places for consumers to download the TikTok app.

Shannon Reaves, a spouse successful Stroock's CFIUS compliance group, said immoderate request connected a 3rd enactment would not travel from CFIUS, which is tasked with evaluating overseas investments alone.

"There won't beryllium enactment from CFIUS arsenic a effect of this reappraisal that volition beryllium taken against 3rd parties that are not a portion of this transaction," Reaves said. "So your Apples and your Googles and truthful forth, that that volition not happen."

The authorities whitethorn person to crook to authorities oregon enforcement orders to get app distributors, ISPs and unreality services to artifact entree to TikTok.

While determination volition apt ever beryllium cracks that tin beryllium exploited by a subset of machine literate users, the emblematic user would find it hard to entree a authorities banned service, said Douglas Schmidt, an engineering prof astatine Vanderbilt.

"There volition astir ever beryllium ways astir this," Schmidt said. "It would conscionable beryllium a batch much hard for the mean idiosyncratic to bash it without getting an precocious grade successful machine information oregon something."

In different words, a VPN won't beryllium enough, successful portion due to the fact that going that way would inactive apt necessitate app store credentials, which volition bespeak a user's location. Gerald Kasulis, a vice president astatine NordVPN, said there's besides exertion disposable to observe erstwhile a idiosyncratic is trying to entree an app with a VPN.

Concerns astir TikTok's information hazard travel down to 2 main issues. The archetypal is who tin entree U.S. user accusation and the 2nd is who has the quality to find what accusation reaches U.S. users. Under Chinese law, companies tin beryllium required to manus implicit interior accusation to the authorities for expected nationalist information purposes.

TikTok has sought to reassure the U.S. authorities that U.S. idiosyncratic information is stored extracurricular of China. The institution has developed an elaborate program known arsenic Project Texas that includes the vetting of its codification successful the U.S. and a abstracted committee of directors for a home subsidiary, with members reviewed by the U.S. government.

TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew, who's acceptable to attest earlier a U.S. House sheet adjacent week, told The Wall Street Journal that Project Texas would bash conscionable arsenic overmuch arsenic divestment to resoluteness immoderate information concerns.

But the temper successful Washington isn't moving successful TikTok's favor, and legislators person mislaid immoderate spot they erstwhile whitethorn person had successful China and its motives. That contented resurfaced earlier this year, erstwhile a suspected Chinese spy balloon was spotted flying crossed a ample swath of the U.S. Biden ordered the subject to shoot down the balloon past month.

When it comes to user technology, users person nary thought what accusation is making its mode to the Chinese government. And the U.S. authorities has a batch of enactment to bash to supply clarity connected what would hap if the app was to beryllium banned.

"Even for idiosyncratic who studies this stuff, it's not casual to detach and detangle each these apps," said Gorman. "As a society, we person not made the determination that the app stores, the Apple App Store oregon the Google Play Store, should beryllium restricting apps based connected the magnitude of accusation they collect. It can't beryllium enactment connected immoderate idiosyncratic and it truly does request to beryllium addressed by governments."

While galore users whitethorn deliberation their casual societal media usage would beryllium of small involvement to a overseas government, Schmidt said that information tin person a astonishing magnitude of worth to atrocious actors.

"Having accusation astir your habits and your interests and your interactions and wherever you spell and what you bash could beryllium utilized for things similar either phishing attacks to get entree to much information, oregon for things similar blackmail, if you're doing things that you mightiness not privation different radical to cognize about," Schmidt said.

It's unfamiliar territory for U.S. companies, successful opposition to China, which blocks entree to each sorts of content, including astir large U.S. net services.

"Trying to constabulary information entree is very, precise difficult, particularly erstwhile there's suspicion that the folks who are doing this person a crushed to bash it," Schmidt said. "And they're heavy incentivized to cod this accusation and usage it for each kinds of purposes."

Subscribe to CNBC connected YouTube.

WATCH: Uncertainty astir the destiny of TikTok sends rival stocks soaring