1 year ago
99 China Report is MIT Technology Review’s newsletter astir exertion developments successful China. Sign up to person it successful your inbox each Tuesday.
If you instrumentality a look astatine app stores successful the US close now, you mightiness beryllium amazed to find they are dominated by Chinese programs.
On Monday, the 3 astir downloaded escaped apps connected Apple’s App Store were Temu, TikTok, and CapCut (a TikTok video editor); the aforesaid illustration successful the Google Play Store was led by Temu, TikTok, and Shein. All 4 programs are made by Chinese societal media oregon e-commerce companies.
While TikTok and Shein person been fashionable for a agelong time, the caller ascension of Temu, a discount buying app that we archetypal covered successful October, is making a caller world clear: Chinese-made apps are having a infinitesimal successful the US.
Their occurrence is partially due to the fact that Chinese tech companies, having survived a decennary of cutthroat contention successful the home user tech industry, tin present beryllium adjacent amended than Silicon Valley astatine making easy-to-use and addictive apps. But it’s besides due to the fact that they are spending generously connected marketing: Temu is estimated to person spent immoderate $14 million connected its 2 Super Bowl ads (in which it besides promised a $10 cardinal giveaway).
The unprecedented popularity of Chinese apps is simply a spot jarring juxtaposed against different communicative presently dominating the quality cycle: expanding bans of TikTok usage connected authorities devices. The US has been trying to bounds the app’s scope astatine the authorities and national level since December. This week, it was joined by the European Commission and the Canadian government, some of which decided to prohibition TikTok connected staffers’ enactment phones. The premise of these bans is that the Chinese authorities could usage TikTok to manipulate what national workers spot oregon to get delicate accusation similar their GPS locations.
The aforesaid attraction could easy dispersed to different Chinese apps. Although nationalist consciousness of their links to the Chinese authorities mightiness not beryllium arsenic strong, immoderate radical are trying to alteration that. For example, the Special Competitive Studies Project, a caller deliberation vessel founded by erstwhile Google CEO Eric Schmidt, specifically named Shein, Temu, and CapCut (as good arsenic WeChat) arsenic apps that “could airs akin challenges” arsenic TikTok in a February 15 post.
There are existent concerns astir these apps’ privateness protocols. But I judge astir of the anxiousness astir having Chinese apps connected our phones is overblown and politicized.
I’m not alone. Kevin Xu, a technologist and the writer down the bilingual newsletter Interconnected, wrote past week that “the DC policymaking ellipse has moved beyond TikTok to conception an all-encompassing worldview wherever each apps made by Chinese tech companies are bad.”
And Xu says adjacent the risks surrounding TikTok person been overblown. “There is presently an evidentiary spread of existent harm that TikTok has done to immoderate existent American that’s of a nationalist information nature,” helium tells me.
Lotus Ruan, who has conducted method analyses of Chinese apps similar WeChat and is presently a elder probe chap astatine the Toronto-based probe radical Citizen Lab, echoes this view: “With the emergence of TikTok and the Chinese apps going global, [people] are looking astatine the Chinese apps with a magnifying glass.” As a result, the risks are often exaggerated.
The existent differences betwixt these apps and American apps are beauteous small, Ruan says. In 2021, a technical reappraisal of TikTok, conducted by a workfellow of Ruan’s, reported that it “did not observe [TikTok oregon its Chinese mentation Douyin] collecting interaction lists, signaling and sending photos, audio, videos oregon geolocation coordinates without idiosyncratic permission.” (WeChat, connected the different hand, was recovered to surveil chats adjacent successful accounts not registered successful China.)
“We person a inclination to securitize everything now,” Ruan says, “It’s important, but we person to beryllium precise cautious erstwhile we use a nationalist information model to data.” Concerns astir what these apps could person been doing should beryllium built connected existent method probe alternatively of speculation and insinuation, she says.
Even so, journalists and those successful argumentation circles should intimately ticker however these apps process their data, with peculiar attraction to whether immoderate idiosyncratic information is being transferred backmost to China.
As Xu tells me, there’s a morganatic nationalist information interest astir what happens to US idiosyncratic information erstwhile it is wrong China’s borders. China has been processing a ineligible model for protecting idiosyncratic data, but it is focused connected holding backstage companies accountable, not restricting what benignant of information the authorities gets from companies oregon what it does with that data.
There are things companies similar ByteDance, which owns TikTok, tin bash to code the concerns. For years, ByteDance has vowed to store and process US information lone successful the US, but determination are still reports that institution engineers successful China are inappropriately accessing US idiosyncratic data. “There are a fewer things they person said they’re going to do, but they haven’t. I deliberation that’s the problem,” Xu says. Enforcing that separation of idiosyncratic data—and utilizing third-party audits to beryllium that it’s being done—would beryllium a archetypal step.
The governmental communicative astir TikTok arsenic a nationalist information menace whitethorn thrust distant immoderate users—if TikTok is nary bully for authorities employees, shouldn’t I beryllium acrophobic and enactment distant from it too? But unless the US authorities implements a broad prohibition connected TikTok, I judge galore much are going to support utilizing it.
The world is, astatine the extremity of the day, precise fewer American users are actively reasoning astir what state an app originates from. Many radical volition simply measurement the benefits and risks: are the goofy videos entertaining capable to warrant the risks of exposing their information to companies and perchance authorities actors?
Reports of factual harm mightiness extremity the balance. But galore radical person continued to usage American societal media apps adjacent aft learning what those platforms are doing with their data. It’s earthy that radical measurement privateness and convenience successful their ain ways, Ruan says. Some radical whitethorn yet determine they are consenting to support utilizing TikTok adjacent if their information whitethorn beryllium exposed to the Chinese government.
The question is whether Temu, Shein, and different Chinese apps that volition inevitably effort to interruption into the US marketplace tin consistently supply their American users with the convenience and amusement that TikTok did. If they can, determination volition ever beryllium an unfastened market, nary substance however atrocious the geopolitical situation.
Do you deliberation Temu volition beryllium treated similar TikTok has been? Let maine cognize your thoughts astatine zeyi@technologyreview.com.
Catch up with China
1. While we’re talking astir TikTok, invited to the chaotic satellite of TikTok Live, wherever radical watercourse themselves pretending to sleep, role-playing robots, oregon doing different weird things for real-time currency gifts. (Insider $)
2. TikTok volition grow its API entree to much world researchers, allowing them to analyse idiosyncratic profiles and activities. But those utilizing the API person not recovered it adjuvant erstwhile it comes to knowing the app’s proposal oregon contented moderation systems. (Stanford Internet Observatory)
3. Inside TSMC’s caller $40 cardinal Arizona mill project, employees are questioning whether the Taiwanese chip-making elephantine has made a bully concern decision. (New York Times $)
4. The caller US legislature sheet connected China began hearings today. Its leader, Congressman Mike Gallagher, said helium wanted to absorption connected however American companies put and run successful China. (Financial Times $)
5. Citizen, the arguable crime-tracking app, is present trying to triumph implicit aged Asian-Americans successful the Bay Area, who person been traumatized by rising hatred crimes. (MIT Technology Review)
6. Amid the ChatGPT craze, Shanghai’s section officials person pledged to pull much than 20,000 radical with AI expertise and 500 AI-related companies to the metropolis by 2025. (South China Morning Post $)
7. Last week, the aforesaid week that Beijing publically called for bid talks betwixt Russia and Ukraine, Washington said it believes China is readying connected sending artillery and drones to Russia. (Wall Street Journal $)
Lost successful translation
In China, TikTok addiction is not constricted to teens. According to Chinese work Shenran Caijing, galore aged radical are present addicted to watching livestreams connected their phones and making impulsive purchases, and their children are worried.
On apps similar WeChat and Douyin, livestream channels are selling fake antiques and dubious wellness products for amazingly debased prices. While young adults tin easy spot the scam tactics, older and little tech-savvy livestream audiences are struggling to separate betwixt what’s existent and what’s not. The scammers adjacent tailor their selling connection to older viewers, promoting products that they assertion volition bless their children’s lives and asking them to support the purchases a secret.
Some household members tried to constituent retired the fraudulent practices successful the remark conception nether those livestreams, lone to person their accounts blocked by the channels immediately. Others tried to restrict their parents’ entree to livestream platforms oregon integer wallets, but the parents soon registered caller accounts. In the end, the much children intervene, the much apt their parents are to fell the purchases from them.
One much thing
Among Chinese tech companies, ByteDance has the estimation of having employees truthful loyal that they can’t assistance telling everyone who they enactment for. During a caller stand-up performance successful Shanghai, a comedian made a gag astir his parent being addicted to watching Douyin. Before helium could finish, a ByteDance worker successful the assemblage called out: “We convey you and your parent for approving our company’s product.” When the comedian responded that the gag was successful nary mode an enactment of approval, the heckler continued to importune it means his parent relies connected Douyin. How acold would you spell to support your leader successful a drama show?
