Choosing between pre-tax and Roth 401(k) plans can be much trickier than you think

4 weeks ago

Prathanchorruangsak | Istock | Getty Images

Whether you're a existent worker oregon changing jobs, you whitethorn request to take betwixt pre-tax and Roth 401(k) contributions, and it whitethorn beryllium trickier than you expect.

Here's the difference: Pre-tax 401(k) deposits trim your adjusted gross income, and the wealth grows tax-deferred, meaning you'll wage levies connected withdrawals. By contrast, Roth 401(k) contributions don't supply an upfront write-off, but net are tax-free.

However, determination whitethorn beryllium different taxation trade-offs, truthful you'll request to measurement the pros and cons earlier diverting funds, fiscal experts say.

More from Personal Finance:
White House tries to fig retired which pupil indebtedness to forgive
There's an 'un-retirement' inclination amid this blistery occupation market
How to bushed backmost rising prices with Memorial Day deals

Roughly 86% of 401(k) plans offered a Roth relationship successful 2020, up from 75% successful 2019, according to the Plan Sponsor Council of America.

"In general, the extremity is to instrumentality deductions astatine a higher taxation complaint and distributions astatine a little one," said certified fiscal planner Ken Waltzer, co-founder and managing spouse of KCS Wealth Advisory successful Los Angeles. 

If you program connected much income oregon higher taxes successful retirement, tax-free withdrawals from Roth contributions whitethorn marque sense, and tax-deferred contributions whitethorn beryllium amended if you expect little net and levies.

But that's not ever a winning strategy, according to Michelle Gessner, a Houston-based CFP and laminitis of Gessner Wealth Strategies.

"Investors are speedy to discard the thought of making Roth contributions if they are successful a precocious taxation bracket due to the fact that they privation the deduction that comes with a regular 401(k) contribution," she said.

However, the upfront write-off whitethorn not beryllium worthy it if you interest astir the consequences of taxable required minimum distributions, she said. 

Social Security and Medicare costs

When idiosyncratic withdraws tax-deferred wealth from a 401(k), it boosts their income, which whitethorn trigger levies connected Social Security and hike Medicare premiums. 

The formulas for Social Security taxes, Medicare Part B and Medicare Part D usage alleged modified adjusted gross income, oregon MAGI.

If fractional of your Social Security payments positive MAGI is much than $34,000 ($44,000 for a associated return), up to 85% of those benefits whitethorn beryllium taxable.

However, the bigger contented for retirees supra definite income levels whitethorn beryllium the surcharge for Medicare Part B, known arsenic the Income Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, oregon IRMAA.  

While the basal magnitude for Medicare Part B premiums is $170.10 for 2022, payments spell up erstwhile income exceeds $91,000 ($182,000 for associated filers). The calculation uses MAGI from 2 years prior.     

Roth withdrawals, however, won't amusement up connected taxation returns, said Gessner, meaning retirees don't person to interest astir these distributions causing Medicare premium increases.

Diversify taxes

Since nary 1 tin foretell aboriginal taxation rates, you whitethorn besides see creating a premix of pre-tax and after-tax funds from a diversification standpoint, experts say.

"It is large erstwhile clients person some Roth and accepted status savings," said Catherine Valega, a CFP and wealthiness advisor astatine Green Bee Advisory successful Winchester, Massachusetts.

If you person some pre-tax and after-tax funds, it whitethorn supply much options to trade an businesslike status income plan, she said.