Professional Book Nerd vs. ChatGPT: Who Recommended Better

9 months ago 77

This contented contains affiliate links. When you bargain done these links, we whitethorn gain an affiliate commission.

With each this chatter that ChatGPT volition instrumentality implicit the world, those of america implicit astatine Tailored Book Recommendations (TBR) decided to spot if AI is astir to enactment america each retired of work. TBR is our subscription based work that matches customers with their ain nonrecreational publication nerd, AKA bibliologist, who recommends 3 books per 4th based connected the customer’s interests. When customers motion up for TBR, they capable retired a abbreviated survey astir their speechmaking likes and dislikes, and fto america cognize if there’s thing successful peculiar they privation to explore. Armed with a mates illustration surveys and a ChatGPT login, I acceptable retired to spot if I, an existent quality bibliologist, could out-recommend ChatGPT’s algorithms.

Customer Number 1

First up, lawsuit fig 1 is simply a large instrumentality of fantasy, sci-fi, speculative fiction, YA, and horror. They’re looking to research much phantasy from non-Western viewpoints, bask books with aggregate narrators, and would similar to agelong a small spot extracurricular their comfortableness zone. Their favourite caller reads see City of Brass by S.A. Chakraborty, Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo, and Feed by Mira Grant. The lawsuit would similar to debar immoderate books that incorporate unit towards animals.

Recommendation Number 1 

ChatGPT picked The Poppy War by R.F. Kuang: “This epic phantasy caller draws inspiration from Chinese past and mythology, offering a gripping communicative of war, politics, and a determined young protagonist.”

An fantabulous book! But not close for this lawsuit since it includes graphic unit towards animals, which the lawsuit specifically asked to avoid. 

The Final Strife by Saara El-Arifi Book Cover

Instead, I’d spell with The Final Strife by Saara El-Arifi. It’s an epic phantasy that follows 3 interconnected characters arsenic they navigate a nine wherever the colour of one’s humor determines their role. This 1 is cleanable for this lawsuit since it is told done aggregate perspectives and takes its inspiration from Arabian and African mythologies, fulfilling the petition for non-Western fantasy.

Book Deals Newsletter

Sign up for our Book Deals newsletter and get up to 80% disconnected books you really privation to read.

Thank you for signing up! Keep an oculus connected your inbox.

By signing up you hold to our terms of use

Recommendation Number 2

ChatGPT went with Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel: “This post-apocalyptic caller explores the interconnected lives of assorted characters before, during, and aft a devastating pandemic. It focuses connected their resilience, creativity, and the value of creation successful preserving humanity.”

Another large work — 1 of my favorites successful fact. But I wouldn’t urge it to a TBR lawsuit since it’s already precise fashionable and adjacent has a TV adaptation. One of the benefits of TBR is we debar picking books that already person a wide readership and alternatively hunt for much under-the-radar reads that customers aren’t arsenic apt to person recovered connected their own. 

We Have Always Been Here by Lena Nguyen publication  cover

My prime would beryllium We Have Always Been Here by Lena Nguyen; a intelligence fearfulness caller acceptable aboard a spaceship sent to colonize a distant moon. I deliberation it’d beryllium a bully acceptable for the lawsuit since they bask some sci-fi and horror, and the book’s futuristic mounting and inclusion of android characters besides pushes it into the speculative category.

Recommendation Number 3 

Chat GPT suggested continuing the Daevabad Trilogy by S.A. Chakraborty since the lawsuit loved The City of Brass: “Since you enjoyed this book, you whitethorn besides privation to proceed with the remainder of the Daevabad Trilogy, including The Kingdom of Copper and The Empire of Gold. This trilogy is affluent successful Middle Eastern mythology, governmental intrigue, and analyzable characters.”

Book screen  of The Keeper of the Night by Kylie Lee Baker

Ah yes, due to the fact that a lawsuit who enjoyed the archetypal publication successful a bid decidedly needs a nonrecreational to suggest they work the second. File this under, “things your bibliologist volition ne'er do.” Instead, I’d spell with The Keeper of the Night by Kylie Lee Baker. Not lone is it an imaginative YA phantasy that weaves British and Japanese folklore, but it besides branches retired immoderate from the customer’s accustomed interests with its humanities London setting. 

Customer Number 2

Let’s effort different one! Our 2nd hypothetical lawsuit wants their recommendations to see a nonfiction publication by an writer from a marginalized community, wants to grow their literate horizons, and would similar astatine slightest 1 publication that’s lighter successful tone. They precocious enjoyed The Ugly Cry by Danielle Henderson, A Master of Djinn by P. Djèlí Clark, and Front Desk by Kelly Yang. They work immoderate genre and are anxious to effort a premix of recommendations, truthful there’s tons of country to play here.

Recommendation Number 1 

ChatGPT chose Becoming by Michelle Obama: “In this memoir, erstwhile First Lady Michelle Obama reflects connected her life, from her puerility connected the South Side of Chicago to her years successful the White House. It offers insights into her idiosyncratic journey, achievements, and the interaction she has had connected the world.”

 A Memoir

Again, considering that this was one of the champion selling books of 2018, I don’t deliberation anyone needs to beryllium reminded it exists, arsenic bully arsenic it is.  

Instead, I would spell with Hijab Butch Blues by Lamya H. It’s a recently released memoir by an anonymous queer Muslim woman. With immoderate akin themes arsenic The Ugly Cry, including coming-of-age and belonging, I deliberation the lawsuit volition bask this unsocial position and beryllium drawn successful Lamya’s beardown voice.

Recommendation Number 2

ChatGPT went with The Poppy War again. 

I conjecture I tin spot wherefore ChatGPT recommended this book, but since the lawsuit is looking to effort caller things, let’s spell for much of a hidden gem, shall we?

cover of Across a Field of Starlight by Blue Delliquanti

I’d urge a graphic caller called Across a Field of Starlight by Blue Delliquanti. Featuring dreamy illustrations, the communicative follows 2 nonbinary characters from other sides of an interplanetary warfare who collide and signifier a heavy relationship that whitethorn turn into more. Since the lawsuit doesn’t notation speechmaking graphic novels, I deliberation this volition beryllium a large mode for them to research a new-to-them genre portion keeping with the hopeful code they’ve enjoyed successful different books.

Recommendation Number 3 

ChatGPT chose The House connected the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune: “This heartwarming phantasy caller follows a caseworker who is sent to measure an orphanage for magical children. It explores themes of recovered family, acceptance, and the powerfulness of emotion and kindness.”

Book screen  of Mango, Mambo, and Murder

Another missed accidental for a hidden gem! Since this lawsuit wants to beryllium recommended a premix of genres, I decided to spell with Mango, Mambo, and Murder by Raquel V. Reyes — a cozy enigma astir a nutrient anthropologist who winds up needing to lick a murder. It hits connected the customer’s petition for a airy work portion inactive being extracurricular their comfortableness zone.

When it comes down to it, ChatGPT isn’t awful astatine recommending books, it conscionable isn’t precise creative. If you inquire it for sci-fi, you’ll get Brandon Sanderson and Frank Herbert. Ask for fearfulness and it’ll churn retired Stephen King and Shirley Jackson. Request literate fabrication and it’ll suggest F. Scott Fitzgerald and Harper Lee. And arsenic we saw, it tends toward recommending champion sellers, and, unless you specify you’re looking for diversity, achromatic authors. It can’t look to fig retired however to debar books that incorporate definite triggers and doesn’t truly grasp the petition to grow literate horizons. This experimentation shows that erstwhile again, AI is simply a utile instrumentality that tin beryllium outdone by a existent quality brain. If you’re funny successful seeing what a existent quality being recommends for your adjacent favourite book, travel cheque retired TBR!

Read Entire Article