This Paradox Splits Smart People 50/50
Two boxes. One is transparent and holds a known sum; the other is opaque and may hold much more — if a predictor foresaw your choice correctly. Newcomb’s Paradox has split philosophers, mathematicians and economists down the middle, and this Veritasium film asks why.
The paradox pits two principles of rational choice against each other: maximise expected utility, or act only on what your choice causes. With contributions from Dr. Arif Ahmed, Dr. Adam Elga, Dr. Kenny Easwaran, Dr. Peter Slezak, Dr. David Wolpert, Dr. Scott Aaronson and Dr. Michael Huemer, the film follows the argument from free will to mutually assured destruction — and to the strange power of precommitment.
Key Themes & Topics Examined
- The setup of Newcomb’s Paradox and its two boxes.
- Causal versus evidential decision theory.
- What the paradox says about free will.
- Competing definitions of rationality.
- The analogy to mutually assured destruction.
- Precommitment as a strategy.
Archival & Investigative Sources
- Academic contributions from Dr. Arif Ahmed, Dr. Adam Elga, Dr. Kenny Easwaran, Dr. Peter Slezak, Dr. David Wolpert, Dr. Scott Aaronson and Dr. Michael Huemer.
- References to academic posts, including one by Professor Huemer on causal expected utility calculation.
Recommended Companion Viewing
Explore authoritative investigative documentaries on related historical events and investigative subjects.
Do We Know How Magnets Work Yet?
The Mystery of Water: Nature’s Strangest Liquid
What Happens If You Drop 0.125 Grams of Antimatter?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Newcomb’s Paradox?
Newcomb’s Paradox is a thought experiment involving a choice between two boxes, where a predictor has accurately foreseen the participant’s decision. One box is transparent and contains a known amount, while the other is opaque and may contain a larger sum, depending on the predictor’s forecast of the participant’s choice.
How does Newcomb’s Paradox relate to free will?
The paradox raises questions about the nature of free will by suggesting that a predictor can accurately foresee a person’s choices, which can be interpreted as implying a deterministic universe or challenging the traditional understanding of autonomous decision-making.
What is decision theory?
Decision theory is an interdisciplinary approach to identifying the values, uncertainties, and other issues relevant to a given decision, its rationality, and the resulting optimal choice. It encompasses various frameworks, including causal and evidential decision theory, which offer different perspectives on how to make rational choices under uncertainty.


