Teen Manipulated Into Murdering Her Best Friend
In October 2022, twenty-one-year-old Grace Jennings was brutally murdered with a sword inside a garage in Santa Fe, New Mexico. Kiara McCulley, who was nineteen, carried out the attack. But investigators soon uncovered evidence pointing to something even darker. McCulley’s boyfriend, Isaac Apodaca, had allegedly manipulated, encouraged and helped orchestrate the murder through disturbing messages, bizarre claims about a secret society called Ghost, and a web of coercion and control.
Grace Jennings knew both of them. She had known McCulley since second grade, and she had been invited to spend the night at the home McCulley shared with Apodaca, a detached garage at a Santa Fe residence. On 29 October 2022, at about 1:44 in the afternoon, Santa Fe police officers responding to a report of a possible homicide found her body in the garage, with a bloody sword nearby. She had suffered numerous stab and slash wounds from a thirty-six-inch sword, and injuries to her neck consistent with attempts to decapitate her.
The story that emerged in the investigation was stranger than the crime itself. McCulley told investigators that Apodaca was the leader of a secret organisation called Ghost, which, she said, got rid of people who were in charge of sex trafficking or hurting children, and that he kept telling her to kill Jennings so that she could move up in rank in her platoon. Prosecutors argued that Apodaca had convinced McCulley that he belonged to Ghost, and that killing Grace would allow her to advance within its ranks. The organisation did not exist. McCulley also described Apodaca’s claims that he was the archangel Gabriel.
The case took almost four years to reach its end. In February 2025, McCulley pleaded guilty to aggravated second-degree murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder, and as part of her plea agreement she agreed to testify against Apodaca. She took the stand in July 2026, at a six-day trial in Santa Fe, and told the jury how Apodaca had manipulated her. On 15 July 2026, the jury found Apodaca guilty of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder, after deliberating for about two hours. In October 2026, Judge T. Glenn Ellington sentenced Apodaca to life in prison plus an additional fifteen years, with parole possible only after thirty years of the life sentence, and sentenced McCulley to thirty years in prison, followed by five years of supervised probation.
The film was made before that outcome, and it presents the case as it stood at the time: a murder, a manipulation, and a secret society that did not exist. Its subject is not only the crime but the control. Apodaca did not hold the sword. He held, prosecutors argued, the person who held it, through months of messages, claims and pressure, until she did what he wanted. The film asks how that kind of control works, and how a person can be talked into killing a friend they have known since childhood.
What the film explores
The first part of the film is the crime itself: the night Grace Jennings spent at the home McCulley shared with Apodaca, the attack in the garage, and the discovery of her body the next afternoon. The film describes what the police found, and it introduces the two people who were arrested the next day, and the charges against them.
The second part is the manipulation. The film follows the investigation as it uncovered the messages, the claims about Ghost and the archangel Gabriel, and the pattern of coercion that prosecutors said Apodaca had built over months. It shows how McCulley described the pressure she was under, and how the investigators came to believe that the murder had been orchestrated by Apodaca even though he had not held the sword.
The third part is the justice that followed. The film was made before the trial, but the case has since reached its end, and the postscript matters: McCulley’s guilty plea and her testimony, Apodaca’s conviction by a jury in July 2026, and the sentences handed down in October 2026. The film ends with the thought that the most frightening part of the case is not the sword, but the control, and the ease with which one person can be talked into doing the unthinkable.
Key Themes
- Grace Jennings, twenty-one, murdered in Santa Fe on 29 October 2022.
- A thirty-six-inch sword, and injuries consistent with an attempt to decapitate.
- Kiara McCulley, nineteen, who carried out the attack.
- Isaac Apodaca, twenty-five, who allegedly orchestrated it.
- The fake secret society called Ghost, which did not exist.
- Hundreds of text messages, and months of manipulation.
Production and Background
The film is a Coffeehouse Crime documentary, published on the Coffeehouse Crime channel, and it belongs to the channel’s strand of true crime films that reconstruct recent cases from police reports, court records and news coverage.
The case, when it broke in October 2022, was widely reported for the strangeness of the secret society claim, and it has remained in the news through the guilty plea of 2025, the trial of 2026 and the sentencing that followed. The trial, in July 2026, was covered in detail, and McCulley’s testimony, in which she described Apodaca’s manipulation, was the centrepiece of the prosecution’s case.
Recommended Companion Viewing
Explore authoritative investigative documentaries on related historical events and investigative subjects.
113 Knife Wounds: This Teen Girl Staged Her Family’s Slaughter
The Bizarre Case of Darrell Brooks
Lizzie Borden: The Secret Behind the Shocking Murders
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was Grace Jennings? A twenty-one-year-old woman from Santa Fe, New Mexico, who had known Kiara McCulley since second grade. She was invited to spend the night at the home McCulley shared with Isaac Apodaca, and she was murdered there on 29 October 2022.
What was Ghost? A secret organisation that Isaac Apodaca claimed to lead, and that he told McCulley got rid of people involved in sex trafficking or hurting children. Prosecutors argued that the organisation did not exist, and that Apodaca invented it to manipulate McCulley into killing Jennings.
Who carried out the murder? Kiara McCulley, who was nineteen at the time, attacked Jennings with a thirty-six-inch sword in a detached garage. Prosecutors argued that Apodaca had orchestrated the murder through months of manipulation, even though he did not hold the sword himself.
What happened at trial? McCulley pleaded guilty in February 2025 to aggravated second-degree murder and conspiracy, and testified against Apodaca. In July 2026, a Santa Fe jury found Apodaca guilty of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder.
What were the sentences? In October 2026, Judge T. Glenn Ellington sentenced Apodaca to life in prison plus fifteen years, with parole possible only after thirty years, and sentenced McCulley to thirty years in prison, followed by five years of supervised probation.
More to watch
- Inside The FBI’s Hunt For America’s Most Disturbing Serial Killers
- Birthday Party Trap That Led To A 13-Year-Old’s Murder
- Ivy League Yale Student Murderer: You Won’t Believe Where They Left Her Body
- Christa Pike: The Truth Behind America’s Most Shocking Murder Case
- Lizzie Borden: Inside America’s Most Notorious Murder Case
For another case built on a secret society, Patrick Henry Cronin: Murder, Betrayal, and Secret Societies tells the story of a nineteenth-century murder in which a secret society was at the centre of the crime.







