Who Controls All of Our Money?
Who controls all of our money? It is a question most people never ask, because the answer seems obvious: the government prints it, the banks look after it, and the rest of us earn it and spend it. This 2017 film from ColdFusion, the channel of Dagogo Altraide, argues that the real answer is stranger — and more important — than that. Its starting point is a document that surprised even economists: a 2014 paper from the Bank of England, “Money Creation in the Modern Economy”, by Michael McLeay, Amar Radia and Ryland Thomas, which explains that the majority of money in the modern economy is created not by the government or the central bank, but by commercial banks making loans.
The paper’s point is that the textbook story is wrong. Banks do not act simply as intermediaries, lending out deposits that savers place with them, and nor do they “multiply up” central bank money to create new loans and deposits. In the United Kingdom, electronic bank-deposit money created this way makes up roughly 97 percent of the money supply, with cash issued by the central bank accounting for the remainder. The amount of money created ultimately depends on the central bank’s monetary policy — in normal times carried out by setting interest rates, which influence the cost of borrowing — and in exceptional circumstances the central bank can create money directly by purchasing assets, the policy known as quantitative easing.
The film builds on that finding to ask who, then, controls the money supply. It traces the history of central banking — the Bank of England, founded in 1694 to fund a war with France, and the US Federal Reserve, created in 1913 — and it draws on the film’s sources, which include G. Edward Griffin’s The Creature from Jekyll Island, a critical history of the Federal Reserve, and the campaign group Positive Money, which argues that commercial banks capture the profit from issuing money. The film’s argument is that the power to create money is the power to decide who gets it first, and that the institutions that hold that power — the commercial banks, and the central banks that set the rules for them — shape the economy more than any elected government.
What the film does well is to make an abstract subject concrete. It shows how a mortgage creates the money that buys the house, how a business loan creates the money that pays the wages, and how the repayment of a loan destroys money just as surely as its creation made it. It explains why the 2008 financial crisis, which followed a decade in which bank lending flowed overwhelmingly into property, was in part a crisis of money creation itself: the new money went into bidding up house prices rather than into productive investment, and when the lending stopped, the money disappeared with it. The film’s closing question is the one in its title: if banks create the money, and central banks set the price of it, who is really in charge — and who should be?
What the Film Explores
The film explores the mechanics of money creation, and it does so with unusual clarity. Its central claim, taken from the Bank of England, is that money is not printed and then lent, but lent and thereby created: a bank does not need a deposit before it can make a loan, it needs a creditworthy borrower and enough capital to satisfy the regulator.
It also explores the history of who has held this power. The Bank of England was founded in 1694, the Federal Reserve in 1913, and the film traces how central banks came to set interest rates and act as lender of last resort, while the commercial banks did the actual creating.
Finally, the film explores what money creation means for ordinary people. If most money is created as debt, then the economy needs ever more debt to keep growing, and the people who can borrow — above all, those who can borrow against property — get the new money first. The film argues that this is why house prices rise faster than wages, why debt grows faster than the economy, and why financial crises keep happening.
Key Themes
- Banks create money: the Bank of England’s 2014 paper states that most money is created by commercial banks making loans, not by the government printing it.
- The textbook is wrong: banks do not lend out savers’ deposits, and they do not “multiply up” central bank money into new loans.
- Ninety-seven percent: in the UK, bank deposits make up roughly 97 percent of the money supply; cash is only a small remainder.
- The central bank’s role: it sets interest rates and can create money directly through quantitative easing, but it does not fix the amount of money in circulation.
- A history of control: the Bank of England (1694) and the Federal Reserve (1913) were created to manage a system the banks themselves had built.
- Money and property: bank lending flows overwhelmingly into real estate, bidding up house prices rather than funding new production.
Production and Background
The film is by ColdFusion, the channel of Dagogo Altraide, known for its relaxed, well-researched explainers on technology, business and science. Its sources are listed in the description and are unusually transparent for a YouTube documentary: the Bank of England’s Quarterly Bulletin paper on money creation, Griffin’s The Creature from Jekyll Island, the documentary The Money Masters, and material from the campaign group Positive Money and the Bank of England itself.
The Bank of England paper at the film’s centre is real, and its finding is now uncontroversial among central bankers: commercial banks create money when they lend. What remains contested is everything the film builds on top of that finding — who should control money creation, whether banks should capture its profits, and whether the system can be reformed. The film does not settle those questions, and it does not claim to.
Recommended Companion Viewing
Explore authoritative investigative documentaries on related historical events and investigative subjects.
Neel Kashkari, President of the Minneapolis Fed, on Tariffs and More
Off to Scotland - Happiness, Solitude and Oysters
How AI Is Pushing the Semiconductor Supply Chain to the Limit | Bloomberg Primer
How the rich get richer - Money in the world economy | DW Documentary
Frequently Asked Questions
Do banks lend out the money savers deposit? No, according to the Bank of England. When a bank makes a loan it simultaneously creates a matching deposit in the borrower’s account, creating new money.
How much of the money supply is created by banks? In the UK, bank deposits make up roughly 97 percent of the money supply, with notes and coins issued by the central bank accounting for the remainder.
What does the central bank do? It sets the interest rate on central bank reserves, which influences the interest rates on bank loans, and in exceptional circumstances it can create money directly by purchasing assets — quantitative easing.
When was the Federal Reserve created? In 1913.
More to watch
- Luxury Living and the Ultra-Rich – When Money is No Object
- Overworked Underpaid: The Strange Economics of Essential Jobs
- Economist on How High Inflation Takes Time To Build Up
- The Poor, The Banks & Digital Money
- How 3 Million People Got Locked Out of their Bank
Money creation shapes who can borrow and who cannot, and The Poor, The Banks & Digital Money shows what the banking system looks like from the other side.







